The Past, Present, and Future of MEV | Day 1 | Protocol R&D
Carlos Gonzalez Campo, Ben Coverston, Nitesh, Zano Sherwani
Key takeaways
- Shift to Prop AMMs: All speakers see proprietary AMMs, not on-chain CLOBs, as the near-term path to tighter spreads and lower toxic order flow on Solana.
- Faster Blocks Matter More Than Auctions: Shorter slot times and multiple concurrent proposers are viewed as the single biggest lever to curb harmful MEV; auctions and fee tweaks help only at the margin.
- SIMD-0096 Is Partial Relief: Removing the burn redirected more fees on-chain, but side payments and private routes remain attractive until richer in-protocol signaling is built.
- Validator Revenue Arms Race: FrankenDancer nodes already show higher staking yields; broad adoption will hinge on full Jito-tip compatibility and clear revenue uplift versus Agave.
- Application-Level Defenses Rising: Sandwich-resistant venues like Gavel and wallet-tagged “conditional liquidity” are emerging, signalling a shift toward app-controlled execution logic.
- Aggregator Power Concentrates Flow: Jupiter’s dominance lets prop AMMs pre-screen toxicity, reinforcing the move away from generic order books and toward venue-specific quoting.
On Evolution of MEV and Fee Markets
Carlos Gonzalez Campo frames MEV as contested state, and Zano Sherwani narrows “good MEV” to strategies that avoid negative user externalities. Jito tips still correlate tightly with total priority-fee volume, so they remain the simplest proxy for measuring MEV capture on Solana. The post-2023 landscape is far more capitalized; higher volumes and faster Jito auctions have pushed capture efficiency upward, but also intensified the scramble for block access.
On Transaction Landing, SIMD-0096 and Temporal’s Role
Ben Coverston explains that fast, deterministic landing remains hard because validators run heterogeneous schedulers and block-ordering logic. Temporal’s Nosami service decides in real time whether to hit Jito, send directly to a validator’s Transaction Processing Unit, or combine paths, abstracting that complexity for searchers. SIMD-0096 lifted the burn on priority fees, so more value is now expressed on-chain, yet Coverston notes out-of-band deals persist because Jito is still the only way to express ordering or revert-protection preferences at the protocol level. Sherwani adds a caution: higher validator income via tips also means higher implicit inflation costs for non-stakers.
Nitesh details the structural imbalance
takers can wait for slots they control, while makers must quote continuously, so single-leader 400 ms slots expose every resting order. Prioritizing cancels would just create “toxic cancels.” Coverston argues that true price-time CLOB fairness is unachievable without 10-20 ms slots and robust censorship resistance, conditions years away. Prop AMMs sidestep the issue by embedding market-making logic on-chain; they exploit Solana’s fee-density scheduler by making maker updates tiny in Compute Units and takes expensive, naturally granting cancel priority. Sherwani stresses the term “prop AMM” over “darkpool,” since quotes remain lit. Aggregators such as Jupiter funnel mostly retail flow, letting prop AMMs price tighter because toxicity is predictably lower.
On Protocol Roadmap
Alpenglow, Slot Times and Application-Specific Sequencing:
On Validator Clients and Revenue Dynamics
Firedancer’s tile-per-core design already processes main-net load on a fraction of its capacity. Coverston notes FrankenDancer validators are creeping up the reward charts thanks to faster schedulers and block packing. Sherwani emphasizes that widespread switch-over depends on day-one compatibility with Jito tips, because even small fee differences drive validator choice. For applications, Nitesh says the win is simple: lower end-to-end latency without code changes.
Key actionable insights
- Monitor slot-time reduction and Multiple Concurrent Proposers progress; each 100 ms shaved materially narrows spreads and lowers harmful MEV.
- Track FrankenDancer stake share and revenue data once full Jito compatibility ships; validator migration speed will signal confidence in the new client.
- Follow prop AMM rollout and aggregator market share; if prop AMMs continue to out-quote CLOBs, projects relying on on-chain order books may need to pivot their execution models.
More from Blockworks
Debate How Should Ethereum Scale | PMLS 2025 | Day 2 | Blockchain Design
Macauley Peterson, Dan Robinson, mteam.eth, Max Resnick
Debate How Should Protocols Monetize Blockspace | PMLS 2025 | Day 2 | Blockchain Design
Andy , Tarun Chitra, Joshua Tobkin, Jon Charbonneau, Max Resnick
The Future of Security is Zero Knowledge | PMLS 2025 | Day 2 | Blockchain Design
Marc-Thomas Arjoon, Uma Roy, Dan Elitzer, Dr. Benjamin Beckmann