Skip to content
Blockworks

Permissionless MEV | Day 1 | Protocol R&D

Shea Ketsdever

0:000:00

Key takeaways

  • MEV Is the Hidden Rail: Maximum Extractable Value markets silently route trades, liquidations and arbitrage, making or breaking user pricing and protocol health.
  • Permissioned Creep: Private order-flow deals between wallets, bots and block builders have concentrated power; two builders recently handled 90 % of Ethereum blocks.
  • Technical Roadblocks: Privacy, spam and off-chain trust issues push builders toward capital gates and social “pinky-promises,” recreating Payment For Order Flow dynamics.
  • TEEs as Breakthrough: Trusted Execution Environments allow verifiable, confidential, high-frequency computation, turning previously opaque off-chain steps into attested code.
  • BuilderET’s Early Traction: Flashbots’ TEE-based network already builds 25 % of Ethereum blocks, auto-refunds users and shares order flow across multiple independent operators.
  • Economic Flywheel: Order-flow sharing plus protocol-level refunds lower entry barriers, widen competition and are expected to push Ethereum toward a true second-price gas market.
  • Call to Action: Adoption decisions by wallets, DEXes and rollups will determine whether open MEV rails or entrenched exclusive deals define the next cycle.

On the Invisible MEV Supply Chain

Shea Ketsdever opens by demystifying the single “swap” click. Behind it sits an economy of MEV bots that backrun, route liquidity and even liquidate loans. Wallets already auction most user transactions privately; arbitrage profits are split with users, but only if many bots can join. When access is gated, DeFi merely inherits Wall Street’s Payment For Order Flow model under new branding.

On Why Permissionlessness Is Hard

Three constraints dominate. First, information is money, so public mempool visibility invites frontrunning, yet blockchains are transparent by design. Second, free money triggers spam; failed bot transactions still consume roughly half of gas on major roll-ups. Third, once competition moves off-chain, enforcing fair rules without smart-contract enforcement is non-trivial, leading projects like CoW Swap or MEV-Share to rely on large security deposits or unenforceable social contracts.

On Order-Flow Wars and Market Centralisation

The scramble to monetise user flow sparked exclusive arrangements such as Banana Gun’s deal with Titan Builder. Resulting opacity barred new entrants and forced incumbents to overpay for block inclusion, paradoxically raising user fees. Concentration peaked with two builders controlling almost all sequencing—a regulatory and censorship nightmare.

On BuilderET and the TEEs Path Forward

Flashbots deploys Trusted Execution Environments to run off-chain code that is both private and remotely attested. BuilderET hosts multiple operators—Flashbots, Nethermind and BeaverBuild—who share encrypted order flow, co-build blocks and execute a hard-coded refund rule. Users have already received about one million dollars back. The design targets fully permissionless node operation, rollup sequencing (live on UniChain) and private MEV searcher execution, seeding a virtuous cycle of broader participation and cheaper gas.

Key actionable insights

  • Track expansion of TEE-based builders and whether their market share surpasses 50 %—a tipping point for second-price gas auctions.
  • Monitor wallet and DEX integration choices; routing to open auctions instead of exclusive builders will signal industry alignment with permissionless rails.
  • Watch for regulatory reactions as TEEs enable global, privacy-preserving sequencing that weakens jurisdiction-based censorship leverage.