The Economics of Transaction Landing Under MCP
Pranav Garimidi
Session summary
The presenter discusses how transaction inclusion economics might work in multi‑proposer (MCP) protocols, drawing on prior MCP research but not a specific paper. They argue that consensus models with strong inclusion guarantees overlook that real proposers are rational, bandwidth‑limited actors who will only include transactions when fees exceed their opportunity costs. In MCP systems, a small, stake‑sampled set of proposers rotates slowly, creating a stable environment where small and institutional validators, RPC providers, and some applications themselves can act as proposers and compete to sell inclusion capacity.
The talk separates fees into a small burned base fee, a burned ordering (priority) fee, and an inclusion fee paid to proposers. The inclusion fee becomes the central tool for landing transactions, and each proposer may run its own mechanism or make long‑term off‑chain capacity deals with applications. Because multiple proposers can include a transaction, the presenter expects basic inclusion pricing to be competitive, with higher prices reserved for stronger guarantees or special services. They suggest that censorship resistance in practice will be shaped by repeated commercial relationships and applications’ ability to redirect order flow away from censoring or unreliable proposers.
Key takeaways
- The presenter envisions MCP protocols with a small, stake‑sampled proposer set that rotates slowly, approximating broad participation while enabling stable, repeated‑game economics among rational, capacity‑limited proposers.
- They propose three fee types—base, ordering, and inclusion—with the burned ordering fee determining deterministic priority ordering and the proposer‑directed inclusion fee driving incentives for actual transaction landing.
- The presenter argues that competition among multiple concurrent proposers and long‑term application–proposer relationships can commoditize basic inclusion prices and economically discourage censorship over time.