Skip to content

Thorchain – $RUNE

16 Jul 202411 min

$RUNE is something we want to own during a risk-on market given its high correlation and beta to $BTC. It is a highly volatile token making ample moves to both the upside and the downside, presenting asymmetric opportunities in between. This is an ideal setup to start watching out for more positive price action in order to be ready and opportunistically capitalize during market upswings led by $BTC.

Source: Coingecko – $RUNE’s price since $BTC volatility compressed and ceased making new highs; showing outperformance at the end of 2023 and during the initial inflows to spot $BTC ETFs, yet rapidly giving it all back with a 65%+ downfall since the highs in March. Price is now sitting below key technical levels like the 200-day and 50-day simple moving averages.

There is a lot of caution to be exercised when building a position on a token that is down 20% on the monthly chart versus $BTC and 40% on a 3-month and 6-month scale, yet that still represents a 90% increase and outperformance on a yearly scale.

Source: Coingecko – $RUNE peaked much earlier versus $BTC, in December 2023, than versus USD, in March 2024.

The seemingly strong correlation with majors is a good property to have when most altcoins are bleeding and are victims of the low-float and high-fdv phenomenon. New token launches, characterized by aggressive funding rates and very clear deadlines on a calendar, add a lot of headaches when actively managing a portfolio, both on the long and on the short side. Even though $RUNE’s correlation breaks have a tendency for being aggressive, they also exhibit higher sensitivity and beta to $BTC.

Source: Coingecko – The period between September 2023 and January 2024 show that $RUNE can rapidly reprice and go from being negatively correlated to $BTC to having a strong positive 30-day correlation in a short period of time.

Combining the inherent reflexivity of $RUNE’s mechanism design with the resilience that has been built up after surviving for so many years (including multiple hacks, the collapse of $LUNA and $UST, and the FTX debacle) gives us confidence in bidding on it as one of the outperformers on the next leg up led by $BTC. However, it is worth pointing out that waiting for a clear $BTC uptrend is crucial before entering or building a large position.

Controlled token supply, strong community support, and resilience through past market crises enhance the long-term viability, while tailwinds from the overall market and increased usage of the network boost reflexivity through token deflation. Combined with growing institutional interest and R&D on new protocol features, $RUNE is an asset that presents asymmetric opportunities at certain points of the market cycle.

Source: kaito.ai – Mindshare increased in August 2023, surging again in October 2023 and finally making new highs in positive sentiment in December as the price reached new highs after a 3x, showing a similar pattern later in March 2024.

Note that we are not saying that a risk-on rally will start here and now. Still, rather; we are emphasizing the importance of tracking sentiment around $RUNE and the overall market as we approach key dates such as the U.S Presidential Elections. Sentiment around $RUNE is currently neutral and mindshare has diminished. We want to use these indicators to our advantage and anticipate the next move up now that the price is ~60% from the local highs reached in March 2024.

Source: Coingecko – $RUNE significantly outperforms when the overall outlook is bullish, but losses are amplified during sideways moves or downtrends on $BTC and $ETH.

Operationally, Thorchain needs no introduction as the leading cross-chain DEX (often confused with a bridge). It operates as a Layer 1 with very little competition (Maya is a friendly fork while Chainflip’s market cap of $42M is too small to be considered significant). In addition to the ability to swap native L1 assets while retaining self-custody, lending was introduced in Q4 2023 to support 0% interest loans and further enhance $RUNE’s attractiveness, as more new loans create a deflationary effect on the asset.

This symbiotic relationship between $RUNE (the price) and Thorchain (the economic security of the chain) is key to understanding the risk-reward profile of this bet. Thorchain offers some supply-demand dynamics that are infrequent in other tokens. The token’s supply is controlled through mechanisms such as liquidity provider incentives, node bonding requirements, and deflationary pressures from swap fees and loan repayments. This controlled emission rate reduces inflation over time and creates a favorable environment for scarcity and deflationary pressure.

Source: Coingecko – The majority of $RUNE tokens are already in circulation, and there is a total supply of 500M that prevents inflation from surpassing that limit.

Despite being criticized for the interconnectedness that exists between the use of $RUNE as the base asset for all asset pairs and the overall economic security of the system, Thorchain has already survived large liquidity crises where the network was equally dependent on the price of $RUNE as it is today. Sharp declines on the price of $RUNE tend to reduce the liquidity on the platform, lowering TVL and overall market cap securing the chain, which can result in a chain of cascading failures and mass liquidations.

Nonetheless, this also plays out similarly to the upside. Let’s take the March events as an example of a practical scenario where reflexivity manifested in positive price action. On March 7, 2024, 60M $RUNE were burned from the Standby Reserve to increase the lending caps and onboard more collateral for lending. Such a large decrease in the token supply quickly caused some participants to buy due to FOMO (Fear Of Missing Out), creating a self-reinforcing pattern.

Source: TradingView – The 60M token burn marked the local top and price action has trended downwards since, representing almost a 50% fall.

To understand the significance of this and be ready for future events, it is worth keeping an eye on a series of relevant metrics. One of them is the liquidity fee-to-pool rewards ratio, which currently sits at ~25%. This metric represents how much the network is earning in fees per every unit paid out with incentives, meaning that it has been making $0.25 in fees for every $1 paid out in block rewards. This metric has decreased since a high of 58% in July last year even before streaming swaps and lending were live.

Source: Flipside by banbannard – Ideally we would like to see this ratio increasing as an indication of a self-sustaining network.

Similarly, it is also relevant to keep an eye on the total swap volume that is routed through the network. This number has been declining since the local top in price reached in March.

Source: Flipside by 0xHaM-d

Another pull to leverage is lending activity, which acted as a catalyst to reprice $RUNE at the end of last year, pushing the price by ~350% in the period of time from October to December. All loans have 0% interest and there are no liquidations, following a process where:

  • When a loan is opened, $RUNE is burned – collateral is swapped into $RUNE and burned.
  • When a loan is closed, $RUNE is minted – $RUNE is minted and then swapped into the collateral.

The idea behind this is that lending activity is intended to burn more $RUNE than it mints, thereby reducing the circulating supply and increasing the demand for $RUNE.

  • Opening new loans creates a deflationary effect on $RUNE.
  • Closing loans creates an inflationary effect on $RUNE.

On the pessimistic side, there are caps and other parameters in place (such as dynamic collateral ratios or not allow to open new loans under certain conditions) to prevent hyper-inflation or exceed the total 500M $RUNE supply. On the optimistic side, lending activity benefits the protocol by improving the capital efficiency of the pools, resulting in more real yield that attracts new liquidity providers (more trading volume and fees), and increasing TVL to enhance the economic security of the network.

In practice, what we would like to see is net deflation. A spike in activity in March has been key to achieve this deflationary pressure, with an overall net burn of $13.78M $RUNE (17.78M $RUNE burned and 5.06M $RUNE minted). However, this metric has been painting an uglier picture since $BTC’s price started correcting after the halving.

Source: Thorcharts.org – Lending activity has minted more $RUNE than it has burned sincere June, having reached peak levels of burning between March and April.

There is a strong feedback loop between market sentiment and the fundamentals of $RUNE. For that reason, we don’t want to be the first buyers while the price keeps approaching new lows, but we don’t want to be the last in line either. Caution is warranted because $RUNE is a token that can experience rapid declines in bearish or even sideways markets. Thus, waiting for a clear $BTC uptrend and/or improvement in the measures above is key to increase our level of conviction.

Source: Thorchain.net/insights – In addition to the deterministic value calculated based on TVL and market cap requirements, the value of RUNE is influenced by a speculative premium marked by market sentiment.

One notable announcement took place in May when Fireblocks announced that it will be supporting Thorchain. This is relevant considering that Fireblocks is the platform of choice for institutions to manage their assets. In addition to that, this integration also paves the way for institutions to securely bond to a THORNode or provide liquidity, in addition to just holding $RUNE. This may signal that after such a prolonged period of time and having survived multiple cycles, $RUNE might have grown and become an asset that is too big to be ignored by large capital allocators.

After the launch of lending and streaming swaps, other catalysts on the horizon include minor releases like support for an order book and limit orders. While this will be important to replicate the UX of CEXs, we don’t think they will move the needle too much in terms of price appreciation.

Importantly, our decision-making process will put most of the weight and emphasis on price action. Most likely this will involve buying on the way up and even doubling down as the price climbs higher. The size and degree of conviction will be determined by our ability to anticipate and frontrun potential deflationary pressure coming from increasing swap volume or large amounts of tokens being burnt by users taking loans against $BTC or $ETH collateral.

That is to say that with $RUNE there is no need to await or come up with a narrative other than the belief that price itself will create the narrative, grabbing the attention of more eyeballs that ideally would translate into increasing adoption and network activity, drawing in more users and creating more publicity as a result. As long as the fundamental conditions keep improving, this loop can self-reinforce and lead to sustained growth for $RUNE.

Source: Coingecko – The RUNE/ETH and RUNE/BTC ratios have been declining since the peak in November 2023, only bouncing in March 2024. We would like to see this bottom out and start trending upwards before putting the initial capital in.

Black swans and other unexpected risks could neglect the long-term potential, but tracking the liquidity risk is something that we can do in order to estimate any drop in trading volume. Seeing liquidity outflows would definitely be a bad sign, leading to poor trade execution and reduced platform activity. User confidence is key and we would cut any outstanding position we may have in the event that we saw prolonged underperformance or an exodus of participants. Reflexivity hits both ways, and we don’t want to be caught during a decline. Instead, we want to opportunistically enter during an uptrend and let price create a new narrative as it reaches new highs.

Once the position has been built, assuming we are invested while $BTC makes new highs, the key will be to not be caught off guard and hit the cash register frequently. It is the slow and silent risk that kills you and, at some point, regardless of the overall market outlook, profits need to be realized in anticipation of new catalysts, not when the information has been telegraphed and the price already reflects it. In that regard, Thorchain is a team that keeps working on R&D efforts whose releases might take a long time. One of those releases might be perpetuals, but we don’t think this will be coming any time soon.

Regardless, we don’t think it is reasonable to expect outperformance during a sideways boring market like the one we have had in the past months. We advocate for taking a conservative approach where patience will be rewarded. For that reason we are setting our expectations very low when it comes to labeling Vultisig or Project as triggers for a price rerating – at least for now, although any tailwinds coming from that front are more than welcome.

That being said if it survived $LUNA and FTX, it certainly can stomach price drawdowns attributed to randomness. That doesn’t mean we are ignoring or overlooking all risks involved in such a complicated system. Instead, that means that’s what we expect the rest of the market participants to do – we assign low probabilities to anyone trying to economically exploit Thorchain or poke holes in its game-theoretical mechanism design when the overall market is bullish and a U.S. election might be giving us an extra economic stimulus.

Ultimately, when to take action on this thesis is largely dependent on the market outlook of each individual. Some might opt in for a slow accumulation at a specific price level, while others might want to trade momentum and wait for more clarity on $BTC’s race to new all-time highs. $RUNE is a very volatile token that should be treated carefully in order to avoid large drawdowns. We think that losses should be cut early and that there will be plenty of opportunities to get bigger on the position during the rest of the year.

Disclosures

Alea Research has never had a commercial relationship with Thorchain and this report was not paid for or commissioned in any way.

Members of the Alea Research team, including those directly involved in the analysis above, may have positions in the tokens discussed.

This content is provided for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice. You should do your own research and only invest what you can afford to lose. Alea Research is a research platform and not an investment or financial advisor.

Alea Research · 16 Jul 2024 · 11 min

Back to top