Skip to content

Solana – $SOL

16 Jul 202422 min

Introduction

In crypto, investors often find themselves drawn to the use of $BTC and $ETH as performance benchmarks. Bitcoin’s steadfast presence as the Polar Star, and Ethereum’s role as a programmable layer for money and trustless systems, laid out the groundwork to realize the vision of what decentralized ownership of a network actually represents.

Both $ETH and $BTC are the current indisputable leaders in market capitalization and have successfully been approved to be traded in US spot ETFs. While this paves the way for institutional adoption and enhances the recognition of crypto as an asset class, we cannot overlook the fact that, after a decade and billions in investments, the elusive “killer app” for crypto remains undiscovered — one that the everyday person will feel severe pain if it were taken away from them.

The following is not a thesis on Solana where we express optimism and a bullish outlook for the potential approval of a spot ETF. Instead, we will go beyond the network’s resilience since the collapse of FTX and highlight its differentiating value proposition as the main driver behind a compelling opportunity: the fast lane for the adoption of crypto as an asset class.

The industry now stands at a crucial juncture where the next few years will determine whether blockchains can actually transform the world or remain confined to niche applications. If we are to realize this potential, then a scalable infrastructure and Layer 1 is a critical requirement, and Solana can play that role thanks to its differentiating factors from Ethereum. There is no one-size-fits-all solution, and the trade-offs that Solana makes, sacrificing some degree of decentralization for enhanced performance and dApp composability, uniquely position $SOL to power the actual transition from an online to an on-chain world – one that is also powered by high throughput and low transaction costs.

Currently, some of the intrinsic properties that give value to Ethereum are not exclusive to it. What truly sets blockchains apart is their adoption and activity levels, not only looking at the past and present but also projecting further growth into the future. Solana’s technological readiness and growing ecosystem provide the fastlane to accelerate the promises of Ethereum’s scalability roadmap, which has traditionally been characterized as being highly academic and rather slow.

The investment thesis for $SOL has nothing to do with the most recent announcements or possibilities of having a spot ETF. Instead, the upside hinges on the belief that the demand for faster and cheaper transactions will increase rapidly, and if we truly want to unlock use cases that are uniquely enabled by blockchains today, then we have to be aware that the clock is ticking. To capitalize on such an opportunity it is imperative to pick the fastest horse and not be fooled by academic or research-driven approaches that are prone to keep moving the goalposts, breaking composability and fragmenting liquidity as a result.

Overview

Solana was designed from the ground-up by low-level engineers with the ambition of maximizing hardware to build a blockchain that could offer unmatched performance. This ruthless prioritization might make it seem as if decentralization and censorship-resistance had been put to the side, but that’s not really the most accurate way to frame it. While there are tradeoffs involved, Solana ultimately prioritizes the properties that most users and application builders demand: low fees, low latency, and high throughput (i.e. cheap and fast). As hardware capabilities advance, Solana scales accordingly, embodying Moore’s law (i.e. hardware capacity doubles every two years). Therefore, in Solana, provided that the current challenges are overcome, the only bottleneck is business.

The Solana story began in 2017 when the founding team led by Anatoly Yakovenko and Raj Gokal set out to execute their vision of creating a blockchain that could match the performance of a single machine. Provided that software did not get in the way of hardware, the performance of the network could theoretically grow linearly with hardware advancements. This would be achieved by designing an efficient communication method for nodes to eliminate bandwidth as a bottleneck. In Anatoly’s words, “We want to synchronize the world at the speed of light”.

In order for a decentralized set of nodes to match the performance of a single node, that implies that bandwidth cannot be the bottleneck, but rather computation – the first optimization step should be how nodes communicate. Drawing on Anatoly’s experience at Qualcomm, he likened this challenge to how telecommunication companies overcame the bandwidth constraints of radio towers – at scale, no single radio tower has enough bandwidth to give each cell phone its own radio frequency to transmit on.

A concept known as TDMA (Time Division Multiple Access) is what unlocked massive scalability in cellular networks. TDMA dictates that towers divide each radio frequency into time slots, and allocate these time slots to each phone call. This way cell towers could provide a globally available clock for a network, which drastically increases the scalability of the initially limited bandwidth by now letting each frequency support multiple simultaneous data channels.

Looking at the problem from first principles we notice that all blockchains have a “clock problem” (in order to come to a consensus, at least 51% of the machines in the network must execute the same transactions in the same order at the same time) where the clock only ticks when a new block is produced – for Ethereum that happens every 12 seconds, and for Bitcoin approximately every 10 minutes. Hence, the TDMA-equivalent solution for a blockchain would be achieved by having a global clock with sub-second granularity that all nodes can agree on. This is where Proof of History (PoH) comes in – it is not a consensus protocol or anti-sybil mechanism, but rather a solution to the clock problem.

The actual breakthrough saw the light in a whitepaper published by the end of 2017 introducing Proof of History (PoH)—a mechanism for maintaining time between untrusting computers. Having a verifiable global clock simplifies network synchronization. Unlike other chains that require validators to synchronize by communicating with each other, each Solana validator has its own clock – enabling the chain to process transactions almost instantly. Validators are constantly running the PoH algorithm in one of their CPU cores, allowing them to independently track the passage of time and start executing transactions as soon as they arrive (other nodes can receive transactions out of order but still process them in order, as the PoH timestamp provides the canonical order).

Proof of History (PoH) provides a synchronized clock for efficient transaction processing without peer-to-peer communication, while Tower BFT leverages this for network consensus, ensuring that all parts of the network agree on what transactions are valid without constant communication. Drawing inspiration from BitTorrent, Solana also uses a block propagation called Turbine, which makes it possible to break down and distribute data in small pieces. This is further optimized with Gulf Stream, which is a mempool-less transaction forwarding protocol that allows to speed up confirmation times by sending transactions to the appropriate network nodes in advance. Additionally, Sealevel provides a parallel run-time for smart contracts, allowing multiple transactions to be processed at the same time.

Source: LinkedIn – Solana was designed to not be slowed down by consensus, optimizing for fast data propagation and maximizing hardware capabilities.

Unlike other chains that process transactions sequentially, only allowing one contract at a time to modify the state of the chain, Solana’s Sealevel runtime can process tens of thousands of contracts in parallel using as many cores as are available to the validator. This is possible because transactions describe the pieces of state that they will be interacting with in advance (Ethereum validators only know this after they begin executing), allowing for non-overlapping transactions to be executed concurrently (also for transactions that are only reading the same state).

Source: Decentralised.co – Unlike Ethereum, Solana is multi-threaded and can execute transactions in parallel.

The chain officially launched in 2020 with ultra-cheap transaction costs and a developer experience that differentiated it from the abundance of EVM alternatives. This coincided with $BTC and $ETH making new lows after the COVID crash. The lowest-ever market valuation took place in May 2020 at $240M FDV, which is 12 times more than the seed valuation. In 2021 $SOL soared by more than 50,000% from $2 in January 2021 to an all-time high of $259.96 in November of that same year. One year later the rapid growth was overshadowed by the collapse of FTX, bringing the price back down below $15 (almost 10 times lower than the current market price).

Source: TradingView

To this day the end goal and mission remain the same: to achieve one giant state machine for everything and synchronize all the bits for that state machine as fast as physics allow.

Sector Outlook

There will never be a perfect blockchain and debates confronting Ethereum and Solana are missing the whole point of why multiple blockchains coexist – they offer different value propositions. Every chain must navigate a series of trade-offs between decentralization, scalability, security, and performance – and each of these properties cannot be measured in absolute terms, but rather localized on a spectrum. Ethereum prioritizes decentralization, liveness, and security, leading to higher costs and lower performance, whereas Solana focuses on delivering high throughput with low transaction fees at the expense of higher validator costs and requirements, unforced downtime, and networking issues.

Ethereum’s modular approach and scalability roadmap–delegating functions like Data Availability (DA) to separate layers like Celestia or EigenDA, and Layer 2 solutions for execution–acknowledges its inherent scalability issues. This unbundling of functionalities complicates assessments of value accrual to the $ETH token, implying that each component of the modular stack necessitates its own token. At first, $ETH reflected all the value of the ecosystem. Today, however, multiple DA layers and dozens of L2s continue entering the market at hundreds of millions and even multi-billion dollar valuations – and all of this pressure needs to be absorbed by the market either by a rotation of capital or accommodating new capital coming in.

The Costs of Modularity

While Ethereum used to do settlement, DA, and execution, now it is moving towards becoming a settlement layer, and the market has yet to determine how much value accrues to each part of the stack. Put simply, $ETH used to accrue all the value of the economic activity powered by its own chain, but this value is now leaked to DA layers, L2s, AVSs, etc.

The L2-centric roadmap is a detriment to composability and fragments liquidity. In the past, builders developed “money legos” on top of other protocols, but this is not possible when each “lego” lives on a different L2 (and devs must also face the extra headache of picking what L2 they want to deploy on – for which there is an abundance of generalized chains with very little differentiating factors from each other). This fragmentation contrasts with Solana’s integrated solution, with all value accruing to a “monolith” and composable ecosystem powered by $SOL.

The proponents of “modular chains” advocate primarily for the separation of DA and execution, such that one set of nodes performs DA while another performs execution – and these node sets don’t have to be overlapping, but they can. In practice, however, separating these two functions does not increase the performance of either, and while it can reduce the cost of computing (note Ethereum’s emphasis on lowering validator requirements), this comes at the expense of centralized execution (i.e. centralized L2 sequencers).

Solana’s integrated design is more than a differentiating factor – it may be the key to unlocking escape velocity and accelerate growth. This architecture is structurally simpler and allows developers to focus solely on their core product without being bogged down by the intricacies and complexities of modular systems, which are characterized by immature abstraction mechanisms and incompatibility between layers.

While some argue that the proliferation of multiple L2s with different VMs can allow for multiple rollups to be run in parallel and scale execution horizontally (instead of vertically by beefing up hardware requirements), this only highlights the limitations of Ethereum’s EVM as a single-threaded processor.

A multi-chain economy, even if composed of L2s that share the use of Ethereum as a settlement layer, inevitably incurs hidden costs such as latency, slippage, cognitive overload, and additional fees. These costs increase even more as the modular stack expands to include more rollup chains, settlement and DA layers, third-party bridges, external providers, and more, each demanding a slice of the pie. Contrast this with Solana’s parallel execution environment and localized fee markets (such that if a standalone application sees a drastic increase in usage the whole network does not begin charging more fees), which effectively address the need for dedicated blockspace without the added complexity and costs that characterize a multi-rollup economy.

By definition, each L1 and L2 chain maintains its own state and operates as a standalone asset ledger. The more chains there are, the more the global state of all accounts get fragmented, resulting in negative consequences such as lower liquidity on each given instance (and bigger spreads which are detrimental for volume), more total gas consumption (since a cross-chain transactions implies at least two transactions on at least two different ledgers), and more duplicate computation (which is an inefficient use of blockspace). All of these costs compound across all dimensions, especially for DeFi.

To put things into perspective, it was Vitalik’s Endgame in 2021 which acknowledged that blockchains cannot really scale with low validator requirements. That’s actually the essence of the L2 rollup-centric roadmap, by which Ethereum would make the tradeoff of ensuring cheap verifiability at the expense of centralized execution from sequencers. That way even if validator requirements were high, users could still verify and keep a chain secure.

Leaving issues such as potential censorship at the sequencer level aside, Ethereum’s established presence and extensive ecosystem still faces the challenge of negative network effects–where increased usage leads to congestion and higher fees—and this can diminish user experience and hinder adoption. This is Solana’s opportunity to showcase that certain use cases and applications are “Only Possible on Solana”, such as cost-effective DePIN, on-chain CLOBs (Central Limit Order Books), compressed NFTs, mobile-first apps, confidential transactions, or token extensions. Ethereum L2s will make appchains ubiquitous and many chains will emerge with specialized use cases, but we believe that Solana is currently the strongest player for non-EVM innovation (rather than replicating existing functionality with forks). This is key in order to round out the podium and join the vision initiated by $BTC and $ETH.

A Tale of Growing Pains

The Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM), despite its first-mover advantage, also faces significant limitations. Its primary programming language, Solidity, is used only by a relatively small niche of developers who are focused on crypto (nobody uses Solidity outside of the EVM). This user base is tiny compared to the global pool of developers across all programming languages. This limited adoption questions the notion that the EVM has achieved a dominant “Lindy” status through network effects. In contrast, Solana takes advantage of Rust, which has a much larger developer base in Web2, making it easier to attract and onboard talent from the broader tech industry.

The adoption of the EVM is largely attributed to the first generation of developers and enthusiasts who wanted to leverage the programmability of a virtual machine and use cryptography to enable on-chain applications. This is exactly what revealed the inefficiencies of the EVM. Even if the adoption rate remains high across blockchain developers, the reason why the EVM is so can be attributed to how much the developer tooling has improved over the years. It wasn’t until a few years ago that developers couldn’t even test their smart contracts in Solidity (the same language in which they were forced to write their smart contracts), and had to use Javascript with frameworks like Hardhat for testing and deploying their code. This showed that, with enough demand, the tools will catch up, even if the onboarding process takes time and might push back developers with a non-crypto background. Solana is currently at that critical stage where its tools and development frameworks are seeing orders of magnitude improvements, and this will be critical for the years to come in order to experience innovative use cases that are not just simple replicas of EVM code but written in a different language.

Given the current state of applications, we don’t think that there is an app that will be truly enabled by any upcoming parallel EVM that cannot be built on Solana right now. It is hard to see any parallel EVM beating Solana with Firedancer in terms of TPS, and it is unlikely that we see the EVM win performance-wise over the long run. If anything, valid reasons would point at the network effects of Solidity, and perhaps the dominance of EVM-aligned capital for which the switching costs are too high – but this seems to be a weak argument given how early we are in the adoption cycle.

Thesis

Solana’s value proposition is to become a global state machine that operates at the speed of light, offering an alternative to Ethereum’s modular roadmap. Besides the design tradeoffs, we also highlight the importance of network effects, on-chain activity, native token value accrual, and composability between dApps. The simplicity of having all flows on a single monolith translates into a more efficient development process and better user experience. Contrast this with an asset like $ETH, which is progressively being unbundled into separate functions, each with its own token ($TIA for DA, L2 tokens…), and that experiences negative network effects at the base level (i.e the more users and activity, the less usable the network is). We are yet to see how much value goes to the settlement layer, currently embodied by the Ethereum L1, which predominate protocols with a lot of passive TVL and inactive liquidity, such as restaking.

The fact that Solana represents a blockchain design that enables high-performance from first principles positions it to become a foundational layer alongside Bitcoin and Ethereum. It is not a secret that all blockchains come with their own set of trade-offs. Despite many of them marching towards a similar Endgame on their technical roadmaps, this path dependence plays a critical role in determining product-market-fit across different verticals.

The landscape for smart contract platforms has featured extreme power law dynamics, showcasing the unlikelihood that a single ecosystem can support all use cases and applications. This is exactly what makes Solana stand out versus other EVM chains and Ethereum Rollups, presenting an opportunity to eat into $ETH’s dominance through a differentiated solution with a large and growing developer ecosystem.

Currently in Solana, the only bottleneck is the actual business model of any given protocol – it is the destination for product-driven engineers and entrepreneurs. This allows developers on Solana to devote their resources to refining their applications and driving user adoption rather than managing infrastructure. Instead of a highly academic technical roadmap, Solana’s focus on execution is characterized by frequent and iterative upgrades to improve state compression, reduce storage costs, and networking. On that front, the upcoming arrival of Firedancer is the most important item on the roadmap.

The introduction of Firedancer later this year will improve the robustness of the network through client diversity and will increase the chain’s transaction throughput while decreasing the probability of encountering more liveness failures (i.e. the chain goes down). These advancements, coupled with Solana’s ability to scale with hardware improvements, ensure that Solana’s performance will continue to improve over time. All things being equal, Solana can theoretically double its performance every two years without requiring major upgrades, setting it apart from major competitors who are taking a highly academic approach with a heavy technical overhead.

As competitors struggle with liquidity fragmentation (L2s) and scalability (L1s), Solana is positioned with unit costs that can support the on-chain economy, whether it comes in the form of payments, consumer applications, DePIN, or DeFi applications. New entrants on the market aren’t as much of a threat as they are fuel that helps to stand out the unique properties of the chain. For instance, Firedancer’s 55k tps already overshadow Monad’s 10k. It is not only about the hardware but also the innovations in software design that help Solana achieve orders of magnitude more throughput per every dollar spent on hardware.

With a sticky community of developers and easy onboarding, Solana offers an environment where network effects can outpace the Lindyness of the EVM. It all boils down to pragmatism and a philosophy that is centered around practical decentralization. At the heart of this philosophy is the idea that not all nodes are equal, and that node count is a lagging indicator of product market fit – what causes node count to rise over time is less about how cheap it is to run a node and more about how much demand there is to run a node. The more activity Solana hosts, the more individuals, companies, and other organizations will be incentivized to run nodes as part of their operations, causing decentralization to come in due time.

Besides any cultural differences, the properties of blockchains entrench a few leaders at the top: Bitcoin for money, Ethereum for high-value financial applications, and Solana for consumer applications, DePIN, payments, etc. Blockchains are marketplaces for blockspace, where users pay fees to store valuable information and run code, underpinning economies that may eventually surpass those of dominant sovereign nations and their tokens become world reserve currencies on their own. The presence of an implicit social contract results in certain properties that simply cannot be “forked” or replicated by other smart contract platforms, such as liquidity, developer talent, monetary premium, track record, etc.

Only when protocols become standards can powerful network effects emerge. Once a chain reaches critical mass in developer adoption and on-chain activity, it has the potential to experience strong flywheel effects that allow for years of durable economic growth. A deep developer talent pool leads to more useful applications, which attracts more liquidity and leads to greater economic activity, resulting in greater network revenue, investor interest, and more capital available for developers to build in the ecosystem. This is why porting the SVM to an Ethereum L2 or enabling parallelization on the EVM does not represent viable paths on their own – developers want to choose a platform that offers them the greatest financial opportunity and strongest guarantees of sustainability. This is exactly what leaves the top economically relevant blockchains as the most logical destinations; it is not a matter of economic security.

Ethereum has already developed top tooling and has a remarkable track record of overcoming adversity, but we bet that the current market structure still allows for another player to dent Ethereum’s market share. Rather than a single indisputable leader, it wouldn’t be strange by historical standards to emulate a competitive field similar to Apple and Android – a single technical stack just cannot support every single use case for decentralized applications. It is not about $ETH vs $SOL, it is about answering the question of whether the current players are all fairly priced given the magnitude of this opportunity.

For the time being, we view $SOL as a technological play that will remain undisturbed by institutional-driven narratives such as the need for having its own spot ETF. In fact, even if VanEck’s recent filing might make this alternative more viable, the absence of a futures ETF is also a hurdle – making it less appealing to institutional buyers who can’t do basis trades or hedge positions with a liquid derivative.

Reliability, Moneyness, and Other Invalidations

Despite multiple references to Ethereum, we are not advocating for trading the SOL/ETH ratio, although we believe it can be a useful metric to gauge the performance of $SOL relative to the overall market (provided we classify $BTC as a separate asset class), and $SOL’s market cap is about one-fifth of $ETH’s.

There is a lot to be learned from Ethereum’s ethos, and it has undoubtedly set a standard to be referenced by other ecosystems when it comes to decentralization, open-source development, and censorship-resistance. $ETH as an asset also has inherent benefits such as a broad distribution across many stakeholders and open access to the initial supply in the form of an ICO. This is something where $SOL was lagging due to the large concentration of tokens in a few hands, such as FTX. With SBF in prison, this is less of a concern nowadays, but still serves as a reminder that “moneyness” is a very valuable property for a digital commodity.

Source: ICODrops – Solana has raised over $350M in 7 rounds.

It is also worth noting that $ETH has changed its monetary policy on 3 occasions, while $SOL’s has remained stable since 2021 and is yet to experience drastic changes in its fee markets (currently 50% goes to validators and 50% is burnt). While the former has achieved periods of deflation, the latter still faces overhang from locked tokens and a (slightly less concerning since you can stake to avoid dilution) larger inflation rate (or issuance cost).

All things considered, the chain is far from being fully battle-tested or having reached its final state, which is both a headwind and a tailwind. Even though downtimes have been more infrequent over the past year, the chain has faced networking issues that required the core team of engineers to intervene while the chain remained unusable at one of its most critical seasons when large projects were doing their airdrops, such as Kamino, Drift, Parcl, etc.

As Solana matures, we cannot discard the possibility of Solana L2s entering the market. While we believe this is less concerning and will materialize in standalone and isolated instances (like Grass for data scraping, Zeta as a DEX for perps, etc) that won’t break composability or fragment liquidity, we still keep an open mind. There is a non-zero chance that every chain will eventually face its own phase where outsourcing execution might be required by necessity – and Ethereum has already been (and is) going through this.

Also, Solana’s activity has tended to be seasonal, riding different trends such as an airdrop hunting season at the start of the year and a memecoin craze later on. While speculation is usually one of the first signs of adoption, the lack of utility might suggest that unsustainable levels of volume were achieved.

Conclusion

Following a challenging period, Solana rebounded and is now setting up to be more than just a hedge against the EVM and Ethereum’s modular roadmap. For blockchains to thrive there is a need to host unique applications that cannot be built on standard Web2 rails. With use cases that are “only possible on Solana”, $SOL presents an increasingly compelling asset as the activity on its chain continues to ramp up. Even if $SOL manages to grow to only 50% of the value of $ETH, that could already represent a 2.5x or 3x return just by owning $SOL versus $ETH.

It is up to each individual’s conviction to determine the degree of confidence that they assign to $SOL outperforming $ETH as $BTC reaches new highs. While the most recent $ETH spot ETF may be a push back in the short-term, there is still room for outperformance given the relative market caps.

With $ETH no longer being deflationary and activity migrating to L2s while Solana makes new highs in volumes and on-chain activity (even if the majority comes from memecoins), it also begs the question of wondering whether the current revenue levels and market share trends put $SOL in a better position than $ETH in the eyes of the stereotypical institutional investors. Regardless, we have not broken down how value flows through the network, and we will simply resort to treating price as the most relevant piece of information, as that’s what dictates outperformance in an industry like crypto.

References

Disclosures

Alea Research has never had a commercial relationship with Solana and this report was not paid for or commissioned in any way.

Members of the Alea Research team, including those directly involved in the analysis above, may have positions in the tokens discussed.

This content is provided for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice. You should do your own research and only invest what you can afford to lose. Alea Research is a research platform and not an investment or financial advisor.

Alea Research · 16 Jul 2024 · 22 min · 8 sections

Back to top