Skip to content

$NEAR

11 Jun 202422 min

Beyond Competition: A Blockchain Hub

We believe it is a mistake to compare $NEAR to other alt L1s, and this thesis has played out in front of us since the start of the year. Unlike other chains, NEAR is not merely attempting to replicate an ecosystem of dApps that find inspiration on Ethereum. This and similar other narratives miss the mark.

Source: Coingecko – $NEAR has managed to consolidate on a range between $6 and $8 after a strong reprice and almost 4x increase from the yearly lows

Last cycle we saw the rapid surge of $SOL, $LUNA, and $AVAX, with each competing for reaching the price of $100 first and consolidating as the winning alternative L1. At that time, many believed $NEAR could be the fourth contender to bet on a rotation.

Source: TradingView – The bear market kicked in before $NEAR could hold above the awaited target of $20

However, NEAR was meant to be fundamentally different from the early days, and it might have been victim of trying to play marketing tactics and short-lasting games that could help it keep up with its competitors in terms of attention. Besides sharding, a lot of effort went into the Aurora EVM, the ETH<>NEAR rainbow bridge, and even $USN, which was meant to replicate Terra’s $UST and was finally wound down months after the $LUNA fiasco.

The original founder and person behind the actual vision, Illia Polosukhin has now reclaimed his seat as CEO after stepping down. At the same time, the NEAR Foundation has cut staff by 40%, and is progressively coming to the realization that emphasizing its unique selling points and value proposition can make or break the price of action of a token in crypto.

Source: kaito.ai – Token mindshare is moving sideways as price shows strength in the range between $6 and $8, leaving behind past unsustainable spikes in attention

After a strong reprice from $3, the price has held up pretty well despite sentiment dropping, which is a good sign of consolidation after a 300%+ increase YTD. This was not attributed to an AI conference or meeting between Ilia and Jensen Huang (founder and CEO of NVIDIA), but rather signals that many participants were on the sidelines, as they have never really done the work on what NEAR can offer and what it is uniquely able to do.

Source: kaito.ai – Sentiment is bottoming with 3 lower highs while price consolidates above $7, making us think that the next leg up might be coming any time soon

The way we see this playing out is very similar to Arweave and the price action of $AR (up 500%+ YTD), which was under the radar of many people who are now starting to pay attention. The timing for the release of this report does not coincide with a clear bottom phase of sideways and muted price action as we saw one year ago, but we still think there will be more upside and we want to ride the fastest horses as we approach the $ETH ETF inflows and US elections.

Key Takeaways

  • Differentiation: NEAR should be perceived as a L1 with a unique position on the market, and we believe its ecosystem should not be compared to the usual playbook of replicating the existing use cases pioneered on Ethereum.
  • Relative outperformance: $NEAR has shown a strong consolidation after a significant reprice from $3 to the $6-$8 range, indicating solid price action despite dropping sentiment.
  • Technical advantage: NEAR’s approach to scalability through Nightshade sharding is fundamentally different, ensuring perfect composability between shards and addressing security concerns through decentralized and randomized validator assignments.
  • Leadership and vision: Illia’s return as CEO and the NEAR Foundation’s restructuring highlight a renewed focus on emphasizing NEAR’s unique value proposition.
  • Perceived risks: Technical challenges include the complexity of a complete sharding implementation, and the need for effective marketing and business development to attract users and partners.
  • Token economics: $NEAR’s tokenomics include a fee burn mechanism and tail inflation, ensuring long-term sustainability and flexible scarcity, with 87% of the fully diluted valuation already unlocked.
  • Timing and opportunities: We have conviction in $NEAR being one of the fastest horses as we approach the US elections, and we see potential in it being an outperformer that can make up the long leg of pair trading opportunities.

Background

NEAR was co-founded by Alexander Skidanov and Illia Polosukhin. The project’s roots trace back to early 2017 as NEAR.ai, and it wasn’t until August 2018 that they formally started the development of the NEAR Protocol, assembling a skilled team of engineers. In April 2020 the NEAR Foundation was set up as a Swiss-based non-profit organization.

Alex was a senior software developer for Microsoft and later Director of Engineering at MemSQL, a high-performance database company. Illia previously contributed to TensorFlow at Google, and co-authored the base for the Transformer Model (the T in GPT), leading a team at Google Research focused on Deep Learning and Natural Language Processing (NLP).

Source: NEAR Pages – Their combined expertise in systems architecture, machine learning, and artificial intelligence has significantly influenced NEAR’s development. Mainnet went live in April 2020 followed by the $NEAR token launch five months later.

Having stepped down more than a year ago, NEAR founder Illia returned to the role of CEO of the Foundation in October 2023. Since then the core team has been more proactive in developing an AI strategy. This has culminated in the launch of an AI R&D incubator and investment wing to support AI projects building on the NEAR ecosystem.

In terms of fundraising, NEAR has accumulated over $500M in investments since its inception in 2018, attracting capital from investors like Pantera, Multicoin, a16z, IOSG Ventures, and Electric Capital among others. In 2020, after having raised their pre-seed ($810,000 raised with a current 197x ROI), seed ($2.88M raised with a current 148x ROI), and a private round ($8.85M raised at more than 50x ROI), the NEAR Foundation reported on January 13, 2022 the completion of a $150 million funding round. The private token sale was led by Su Zhu’s Three Arrows Capital, with contributions from prominent funds such as Mechanism Capital, Dragonfly Capital, Jump, Alameda, Zee Prime, Amber Group, and others. Three months later, NEAR raised $350 million in a funding round led by hedge fund Tiger Global.

Overview

NEAR is a L1 that achieves scalability through sharding, specifically through a mechanism known as Nightshade. Sharding was the original scalability solution that Ethereum had plans to pursue before the pivot to a rollup-centric roadmap. As proposed by Vitalik in 2018, each shard would contain its own independent state with a unique set of account balances and smart contracts. The unsolved problem was determining how to incentivize and when to allow cross-links, which is somewhat similar to the problem of interoperability across different chains or rollups. In one of his posts in 2021, Vitalik emphasized the importance of sharding: “Sharding is the future of Ethereum scalability, and it will be key to helping the ecosystem support many thousands of transactions per second and allowing large portions of the world to regularly use the platform at an affordable cost.”

9. Blockchains of the future with proof of stake and sharding will be thousands of times more efficient, and so the efficiency sacrifices of putting things on a chain will become more and more acceptable.— vitalik.eth (@VitalikButerin) December 10, 2018

9. Blockchains of the future with proof of stake and sharding will be thousands of times more efficient, and so the efficiency sacrifices of putting things on a chain will become more and more acceptable.

— vitalik.eth (@VitalikButerin) December 10, 2018

Source: Vitalik Buterin on X – In this thread the co-founder of Ethereum states that blockchains will support an increasing number of non-financial applications as scalability advances, driving fees down

Scalability solutions can be broadly classified into vertical or horizontal. Vertical scaling attempts to increase performance by increasing the requirements of each individual node by making them more powerful, while horizontal scaling means adding more nodes to the network.

Source: Medium – Horizontal scaling excels in distributing workloads across multiple nodes. Vertical scaling suits scenarios where a single machine can handle the entire workload efficiently.

Sharding is a form of horizontal scalability that takes the stress off the single chain processing all transactions and interactions with the network. Essentially, it is a technique that divides a blockchain into smaller parts called shards, allowing parallel processing and significantly increasing transaction throughput. Rather than each node having to store all data in the network, they only have to be concerned with the data that is allotted to them in their shard.

Source: Bitpanda Academy – Sharding predates blockchains and originates from a technology called “database partitioning”, which means that a large database is broken up into smaller more manageable databases

Unlike traditional sharding, NEAR uses a sharding mechanism called Nightshade, which creates small portions of the next block called “chunks”. Nightshade enhances transaction throughput by allowing groups of validators to process transactions across multiple shards simultaneously (both the state and processing are sharded). This is achieved through the concept of “chunk-only producers,” which allows validators to focus on a specific shard and produce “chunks” (parts of the block) for that shard without having to track all the shards in the network.

Source: Nightshade whitepaper – The left image shows shard chains while the right one shows one chain with blocks split into chunks.

Announced on January 30, NEAR is currently testing Phase 2 of the Nightshade sharding implementation. This upgrade went seemingly unnoticed but does represent a key milestone for the network, enabling greater scalability and decentralization. It will bring a 10x performance improvement with compressed execution proofs.

Source: NEAR Roadmap – The third stage is not implemented yet and will make it possible to dynamically split and merge shards in response to demand changes.

NEAR also introduces the concept of stateless validations, such that validators don’t need to maintain the state of a shard locally – they can retrieve all the information they need to validate state changes, or “state witness,” from the network. This reduces validator requirements by allowing them to verify transactions without maintaining a complete state. It also facilitates faster and more frequent validator reassignments across shards, which increases security as it makes it harder for attacks to predict validator and shard assignments.

Altogether, this allows NEAR to handle up to 100,000 transactions per second and achieve near-instant finality on transactions, with a one-second block time while maintaining low transaction fees. While still far from roadmap completion, the current state of the network involves 6 shards delegated to 467 permissionless validators. Since validators can validate all shards, NEAR can keep up with high-throughput chains like Solana, exceeding 1k Transactions per Second (TPS).

For comparison, while NEAR’s approach differs from Solana, both represent valid alternatives despite the tradeoffs involved in their respective designs. While Solana achieves concurrency with an integrated system and single state machine that supports parallel transactions (vertical scalability), NEAR splits the chain’s workload (horizontal scalability) aiming to preserve decentralization while increasing capacity. The tradeoff is that sharding introduces latency and delays before finality due to cross-shard communication. In other words, NEAR sacrifices speed for capacity, whereas Solana sacrifices capacity for speed.

What stands out from this architecture is that NEAR can capitalize on second order effects. For example, NEAR DA offers orders of magnitude cheaper costs than Ethereum in terms of Data Availability (DA).

Source: NEAR Docs – NEAR DA provides rollups with a cost-effective solution thanks to sharding, making it possible to process larger amounts of data than Ethereum itself

This versatility is present on multiple components of the stack. For instance, the Rainbow Bridge will transition into an Actively Validated Service (AVS) secured by EigenLayer’s restaking. Another example is the collaboration with Polygon to integrate NEAR DA into the Polygon Chain Development Kit (CDK).

Source: NEAR Docs – One NEAR account can act as a master account holding keys to all chains

Ultimately, this is expected to result in NEAR becoming a large computation network that can sign transactions across a variety of chains. This positions NEAR as an actual “Blockchain Operating System” that can abstract away the complexities of interacting with blockchains, adding value not only to each and everyone of them, but also unlocking new consumer use cases that appeal to a broader audience.

Source: NEAR Docs – Chain signatures enable NEAR accounts to sign transactions for any blockchain by using a multi-party computation (MPC) network and dual quorum security enforced by the NEAR protocol and EigenLayer operators.

NEAR’s Blockchain Operating System (BOS)

While we have metaphorically described NEAR as a Blockchain Operating System that can abstract the complexities involved with transacting across a broad range of blockchains, there is an actual component of the stack that also receives this name.

At least on paper, the intention has always been for NEAR to be developed with a strong focus on improving both developer and user experiences. A major barrier to mass adoption of blockchain applications is the fragmentation of liquidity and users across multiple chains. NEAR tackles this issue by eliminating friction and simplifying the process of interacting on-chain in a multichain world.

Source: NEAR Blog – NEAR BOS is a frontend that facilitates the discovery of Web3 applications, allowing for a seamless one-time experience and removing friction points like making accounts on different chains.

By using a universal account model and cross-chain account abstraction, users on NEAR can trade assets across different chains with fast settlement, and developers can program their applications to support asynchronous cross-contract calls. Chain signatures facilitate multichain transactions from a single NEAR account, significantly improving the user experience. Validators can express costs in the local currency of the chain and convert to $NEAR when reporting on-chain.

Source: NEAR Blog – With NEAR’s BOS anyone can create their own frontend compatible with the blockchain of their choice in a few lines of code.

NEAR made the first step towards achieving chain abstraction on March 2, 2023, when they announced NEAR BOS (Blockchain Operating System) with the idea of empowering developers to build chain-agnostic dApps. In simpler terms, the BOS stood out as a category of its own but went largely unnoticed by the general public. It is meant to be used as a common layer for browsing and discovering dApps compatible with any blockchain, with NEAR acting as the common entry point.

Chain Abstraction

Because of its architecture, NEAR stands out among other L1s because it was built to thrive in a multichain future, abstracting away complexities and offering a cohesive ecosystem with seamless transactions across chains.

Source: NEAR Docs – The idea behind chain abstraction is that blockchains should be completely abstracted away from the end users; users shouldn’t be aware that they are interacting with a blockchain, no matter which one.

The idea behind chain abstraction is to remove the friction and barriers that currently hinder broader adoption. In NEAR, the account model contemplates two different key types: Full-Access Keys, which allow complete account management, and Function-Call Keys, which restrict operations to specific contracts. Onboarding is streamlined through FastAuth, NEAR’s proprietary key management system, simplifying the process for new users.

Source: NEAR Docs – In all blockchains users control their accounts by holding a private key that they use to sign transactions. NEAR accounts present a unique feature of being able to hold multiple access keys, each with its own set of permissions.

Another vital component is Chain Signatures, which enable multi-chain transactions. Any NEAR account can have associated remote addresses on other chains, allowing it to sign messages and execute transactions from those addresses, thanks to the NEAR MPC Network.

Source: NEAR Docs – Chain signatures enable NEAR accounts, including smart contracts, to sign and execute transactions across many different chains

Meta Transactions, introduced through NEP-366, further enhance chain abstraction. This feature allows users to execute transactions on NEAR without needing to own gas or tokens on the chain. This is achieved with relayers, which are third-party service providers that receive signed transactions and relay them to the network, subsidizing the gas fees with their own tokens. This reduces the complexity and cost for users, making blockchain interactions more accessible and user-friendly.

Source: NEAR Docs – Meta Transactions allow users to execute transactions on NEAR without owning any gas or tokens.

Account Aggregation

Account Aggregation on NEAR refers to the ability for users to manage and transact across multiple chains from a single account secured by NEAR validators. This abstracts away the complexities of bridging, owning gas fees in different tokens, and wallet management. Users can hold addresses on various chains and move assets between them effortlessly, interacting with blockchain-based applications without needing to understand the underlying technology.

Source: NEAR Blog – Account Aggregation is achieved with the combination of NEAR accounts, chain signatures, and intent relayers

This is highly beneficial to onboard millions of users from other chains to the NEAR ecosystem, as demonstrated by HERE wallet’s rapid growth through a Telegram integration, which got to 1M users in less than 3 weeks.

Source: Flipside– The growth in the HERE Wallet was kicked off with HotDAO’s $HOT mining on January 31. Over 7.4M wallets have been created on Telegram boasting 4.77M active users

Zooming out we can infer that NEAR vision aims to be the singular interface for all blockchains reducing the necessity for multiple addresses, wallets, and tokens. Account aggregation, along with decentralized frontends and intent relayers, creates a unified user experience, providing a gateway to numerous chains and ensuring efficient cross-chain interactions.

Source: Artemis.xyz – NEAR’s usage has grown by a factor of 10x every year.

The most used apps in the NEAR ecosystem include HotDAO (MPC Wallets), Cosmose (AI-powered shopping), SweatCoin (Walk to Earn), Play Ember (Web3 Game Studio), Sender Labs (Web3 Services), Questflow (Autonomous AI Agents), and more.

Token Economics

As for the $NEAR token, 1B tokens were created at genesis, allocated across various categories. The tokenomics follow a similar model to Ethereum’s, incorporating both a fee burn mechanism and tail inflation to dynamically adjust the supply. Like $ETH, the idea behind this approach is to ensure long-term sustainability and sufficient incentives for validators to join and operate in the network, as well as allow for flexible levels of scarcity and introduce a deflationary effect that benefits token holders.

Source: Coingecko – There were 1,000,000,000 $NEAR tokens created at Genesis on April 22, 2020

Sector Outlook

NEAR’s journey has been overshadowed by other L1s. The fact that NEAR didn’t have a similarly strong community unfairly lumped it to be compared with the likes of Cardano and Polkadot. But the truth is that, even despite opportunistically chasing the latest AI trend, NEAR is uniquely positioned to achieve use cases that are out of the scope of any other player in the industry.

Source: Tradingview – NEARBTC is up 10% since January 1 2024, with a notable 100% increase from a local bottom to a local top between Feb 28 and March 14

Through the establishment of NEAR AI, an incubator and R&D lab, the NEAR Foundation is making strategic investments to optimize the ecosystem for decentralized AI research and applications. This includes investments in core infrastructure for data collection, crowdsourcing, rewarding creators, providing access to computational resources, and other monetization methods that are out of the scope of Web2 ventures.

Source:near_ai on X – The near_ai account went active again after not posting since July 2018

At the technical level, it trails behind some competitors like MultiverseX ($EGLD) and Tonchain ($TON), which have fully implemented sharding. This is not necessarily a big concern, as NEAR’s slower progress is attributed to the commitment to incorporating more advanced features such as stateless validation, which will ultimately enhance scalability even more. This ambition could make NEAR the first Layer 1 blockchain to achieve true scalability through sharding.

Source: Tradingview – $NEAR has substantially outperformed both $TON and $EGLD

We gauge sentiment and view DAUs (Daily Active Users) and MAUs (Monthly Active Users) as leading indicators of a chain’s activity, usually translating into more token demand, initially for gas and then for usage across the ecosystem. While we don’t see the NEAR ecosystem as something comparable to other chains like Ethereum and L2s or Solana, the fact that you can seamlessly interact with those chains from NEAR is a positive point, as it grows the addressable surface even more.

Source: Artemis.xyz– NEAR’s user metrics are in the order of millions and we can see a rapid increase in daily new active addresses during the last week of May

Thesis

NEAR has already broken out from the shadow of its competitors, and as many of the misconceptions now come to light, we believe that Ilia’s solid strategic vision can help to improve market sentiment. The current consolidation phase offers an opportunity for those looking to get exposure to the growth of an infrastructure layer that is fundamentally different to any other alternative in the market.

Unlike other alternative L1s, NEAR wasn’t built to replace or compete against Ethereum and the use cases it enabled. There is also a misconception that NEAR is now pivoting to ride all the coolest and latest narratives, such as DA, restaking, or AI. However, NEAR was built from scratch with a vision that contemplated multiple chains. Rather than viewing each L1 as a competitor, NEAR adopts a positive sum game mentality aiming to grow the pie for the entire industry as a whole. For NEAR, it has never been about TVL, number of transactions per second, or total volume, but rather about increasing mass adoption and onboarding as many users as possible into Web3. When the UX is seamless and frictionless, it becomes much easier to attract new users, developers, and liquidity. The extra building time is worth it.

We view NEAR as the premier hub for on-chain AI combined with the valuation premium that comes with being a L1. By committing to incubate and invest in AI, we trust Illia’s intention to enable actual use cases at the intersection of two of the fastest growing technologies we have seen in the last decades. For instance, NEAR can be the go-to place for the development of User-Owned AI, tapping into the chain’s ability to transact across chains and have agents perform functions on other ecosystems without dealing with the complexities that come with bridges, gas tokens, etc.

Beyond the AI ambitions, we also argue that NEAR has a chance at becoming a fundamental piece of infrastructure that will be crucial for the years to come. Mass adoption requires effective chain and wallet abstraction with seamless interoperability, and while there are many projects each focused on a specific vertical, NEAR can accommodate all of them to take its ecosystem to the next level.

When we look at this thesis from first principles we can clearly see that growing an actual ecosystem is complicated due to large coordination problems. For instance, consider Polkadot parachains, Cosmos appchains, and now the most recent L2 ecosystems with OP Stack chains connected to the Superchain, the Polygon Aggregation Layer, ZkSync hyperchains, etc. Notice how each ecosystem promotes its own solutions. While NEAR is not an agnostic chain or public good, its focus on chain and account abstraction are critical for bridging all of these disparate ecosystems, adding value to each of them instead of being an implicit threat in competition for market share.

Invalidations

At the technical level, one of the things that first comes to mind is that if Ethereum is not using sharding, why could NEAR succeed with this design? One of the primary concerns that comes with sharding often takes the form of asserting that “single shards are less secure”. Critics argue that compromising the security of shards might have negative downstream effects. However, shards come with the same security guarantees that a L1 would. In fact, NEAR addresses this with a decentralized and randomized validator shard assignment, minimizing the risk of a successful attack on a single shard. If an attacker were to DDOS NEAR, they cannot choose what shard they will end up validating. Hence, dominating one shard requires compromising the entire L1, making that probability mathematically negligible.

Another criticism is that “sharding breaks composability”, similar to how Ethereum L2s compete for users and liquidity, fragmenting liquidity and disrupting composability. This is not really an equivalent analogy to what occurs in NEAR, where the design actually ensures perfect composability between all shards at the expense of some latency and time delay, as all shards are identical from the view of the chain’s consensus. This allows for native interoperability with cross-shard transactions. Although there might be a slight delay in cross-shard transactions, it does not equate to breaking composability as seen with L2s, which operate under different rule sets.

From an investing perspective, we have seen time and time again how the best story or narrative usually wins as a result of attracting mindshare. Historically, NEAR’s marketing and business development efforts have faced scrutiny. While this might seem unimportant from a “build it and they will come” mentality, effective marketing and business development are crucial for building strategic partnerships and attracting users. Missteps in these areas could hinder the amount of mindshare that goes to the $NEAR token itself.

Source: NEAR on X – NEAR faced some community backlash over a post about the CEO being touched on the arm by NVIDIA’s CEO. This received community backlash and was deemed awkward and unprofessional

It is also worth noting that the ambitious vision of NEAR relies heavily on its ability to execute on its technical roadmap. NEAR has yet to fully implement its sharding solution, leading some to compare it to ambitious but ultimately unrealized projects. The cynical mind would describe this dynamic pointing out that the incentive to continue tackling such an ambitious goal might go away when every early builder and investor has already been made rich. Without questioning integrity, the ability to deliver on promises is critical for maintaining a competitive edge.

Any failure to fully demonstrate the power of chain abstraction might as well have a negative impact on NEAR’s current market position. The expectations have been set very high and, while NEAR aims to enhance user experience and reduce fragmentation, widespread adoption by users and developers is never guaranteed.

Approximately 87% of the FDV has been unlocked, with the remaining 13% to enter circulation over the next 490 days. There are no cliffs and the future allocation is targeted towards operations, community initiatives and grants, and epoch rewards. This will be a gradual release, which alleviates concerns about potential dilution.

Source: Token unlocks – $NEAR represents the antithesis of the low-float and high-FDV phenomena, with most tokens in circulation and little sell pressure from cliffs and large token unlocks

Timing Entries / Exits

Besides our conviction in $NEAR being an outperformer and good token to hold on the uptrend of a bull market, it is also a token that could be tactically used for pairs trading at opportune moments. For instance, the strength of the AI narrative could present an opportunity to go long $NEAR and short the weakness of tokens with large valuations and a very low float. One could tactically long $NEAR with a short on a token that has substantial unlock and expected sell pressure on the horizon.

Source: Tradingview – $NEAR has outperformed tokens that are characterized for having large supply unlocks since the start of the year, such as $ARB, $OP, $SEI, $APT, or $SUI

Conclusion

Buying something on the way up and being multiples higher than the price you could pay one year ago is not an easy exercise. However, cutting the underperformers early and betting on strength is key to success during bull markets.

References

Disclosures

Alea Research has never had a commercial relationship with NEAR and this report was not paid for or commissioned in any way.

Members of the Alea Research team, including those directly involved in the analysis above, may have positions in the tokens discussed.

This content is provided for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice. You should do your own research and only invest what you can afford to lose. Alea Research is a research platform and not an investment or financial advisor.

Alea Research · 11 Jun 2024 · 22 min · 11 sections

Back to top