Skip to content

MKR vs COMP

22 Jul 202326 min

Overview

MakerDAO

MakerDAO TVL Source: DefiLlama

Primary Chain: Ethereum Mainnet TVL

MakerDAO Website

Twitter

Availability on CEX: MakerDAO’s $MKR is available to trade on most major CEXs including Binance, Coinbase, OKX, Huobi, Kraken, and more.

Compound

Compound TVL Source: DefiLlama

Primary Chain: Ethereum Mainnet TVL

Compound Website

Twitter

Availability on CEX: Compound’s $COMP is available to trade on most major CEXs including Binance, Coinbase, OKX, Huobi, Kraken, and more.

The following report outlines a trade idea on the basis of $MKR outperformance on the long side with a short $COMP position on the other side looking for underperformance on that name.

Even though Maker is a protocol built around CDPs (Collateralized Debt Positions) and Compound is a full-fledged money market, it can be argued that both protocols offer venues for both risk-averse and risk-seeking players. These market participants can meet and exchange services, whether it is by borrowing against volatile collateral or by passively supplying capital to earn yield.

The trade outlined below is not necessarily a bet on the convergence between an undervalued $MKR and an overvalued $COMP. With a 0.42 correlation on a year-over-year basis, there is a moderate positive relationship, but when looking at the past 100 days, we can observe a negative correlation. More specifically, the expectation is that, on a risk-adjusted basis, $MKR will move to the upside and $COMP to the downside. For this reason, it is also important to account for the correlation of each asset relative to $ETH, as that will allow for more flexibility when adjusting position sizes as the trade unfolds and market dynamics change.

Additionally, one could also explore a more direct comparison and come up with a pair trade using $AAVE and $COMP. As a matter of fact, Aave has catalysts on the horizon, as they just deployed their $GHO stablecoin.

It's all systems GHO 👻The Aave DAO successfully launched @GHOAave on the Ethereum Mainnet last week and we're already seeing exciting developments across the DeFi ecosystem 🧵— Aave (@aave) July 21, 2023

It's all systems GHO 👻

The Aave DAO successfully launched @GHOAave on the Ethereum Mainnet last week and we're already seeing exciting developments across the DeFi ecosystem 🧵

— Aave (@aave) July 21, 2023

The normalized prices show the relative change of each price from the first price in the series, starting on June 1st and finishing on July 9.

A Failed Institutional Mission

When evaluating the trade idea between Maker DAO ($MKR) and Compound ($COMP), it is crucial to consider the distinct characteristics and performance of both projects. As pioneers in the first wave of decentralized finance (DeFi) applications, it may seem that both projects share a common goal of institutional adoption while adhering to the principles of cryptocurrency. However, the true measure of success lies in tangible performance rather than branding alone.

Compound, despite its aspirations to become a lending market catering to institutional investors, has faced challenges that set it apart from its competitors. In contrast to Aave, which strategically focused on enhancing protocol revenue, implementing a multi-chain strategy, improving loan-to-value ratios (LTVs) with innovations like Aave’s e-Mode, and even developing its own stablecoin ($GHO), Compound concentrated its efforts on offering institutional liquidity powered by DeFi.

In May 2022, the announcement of the Compound Treasury envisioned a regulated on-ramp tail that would bridge the gap between DeFi and TradFi. Powered by the Compound protocol, Compound became the first decentralized entity to receive a credit rating from S&P Global Ratings. Offering a guaranteed 4% APR on USD and $USDC, banks, fintech, and crypto companies would be able to rely on Compound Treasury as a predictable source of yield.

Later that year, in September 2022, the operations were expanded to also offer borrowing services. More specifically, accredited institutions would be able to borrow USD or $USDC with fixed rates starting at 6% APR using $BTC, $ETH, and other supported ERC20 assets as collateral. Similar to how the Compound protocol works, these loans would be open-ended and would not enforce any kind of repayment schedule.

However, it is essential to note that Compound Treasury has been sunset, and the service currently remains inaccessible. This raises concerns regarding the sustainability and long-term viability of Compound’s institutional-focused offerings.

An Unfulfilled Multichain and Stablecoin Strategy

Compound, from its early days, had the vision to adopt a multichain strategy and even launch its own appchain and stablecoin, positioning itself as a pioneer in this area. However, the project has fallen behind competitors who have successfully embarked on similar journeys, such as DyDx launching their appchain on Cosmos or Aave introducing $GHO.

Initially named Gateway, Compound’s own blockchain was planned to be built on Substrate, enabling a unified borrowing and lending market encompassing assets from various blockchains. Validators appointed by $COMP token holders would earn rewards in the native token $CASH.

The team alluded to multiple reasons justifying the inception of the Compound Chain.

The Compound team highlighted multiple reasons for the inception of the Compound Chain, including aggregating risk across supported assets, addressing high transaction costs in Ethereum L1, and expanding asset support beyond the Ethereum blockchain. To achieve this, Comet, developed by Compound Labs, was designed to facilitate a single borrowable, interest-earning asset, with other supported assets functioning as collateral. The risk management and liquidation engine of Comet were revamped also to enhance protocol safety and incentivize liquidators.

In this framework, each market can be seen as a separate protocol instance with its own collateral and liquidation factors, enabling the creation of tailored money markets with distinct risk profiles deployed across multiple EVM chains.

  • A standalone distributed ledger – Compound Chain.
  • Users can upload supported assets from a variety of blockchains.
  • Users can borrow the $CASH native stablecoin using any supported asset as collateral.
  • Users can transfer and download assets to and from any peer chain address The same Compound Governance on Ethereum will govern the Compound Chain.

Interoperability would be achieved through Starport, a series of connector contracts for the peer chains that live on Gateway. Starport would then be responsible for locking or unlocking assets on the Compound Chain (once validators have reached consensus that an event has occurred).

However, the truth remains that Compound realized the technology was not yet ready. Their strategy primarily focused on developing a custom app-chain on Polkadot or Cosmos, but by the time they recognized their limitations, catching up with the rapid development of layer 2 solutions became challenging. While Comet is operational and utilized in Compound III, its deployment has been limited to Ethereum and, more recently, Arbitrum, where $USDC is the sole borrowable asset. This places Compound at a significant disadvantage compared to previous iterations of the protocol and other competitors that allow for leveraged strategies utilizing diverse collateral options.

Furthermore, the original plan was for Compound to feature its own stablecoin, $CASH, as the borrowable asset. This approach aligns with MakerDAO’s current multichain strategy, where $DAI serves as the unit of account. However, Compound’s deployment of $CASH was hindered, and MakerDAO made a strategic bet on Ethereum’s rollup roadmap, aiming to expand the supply of $DAI across multiple layer 2 solutions.

In light of these challenges, the trade idea of longing Maker DAO (MKR) and shorting Compound (COMP) is further strengthened. Maker DAO’s strategic approach and progress in integrating RWAs, coupled with its commitment to embracing the scalability of L2, position it favorably against Compound’s unfulfilled multichain ambitions and competitive disadvantages

Compound – Losing the Battle vs. Aave

Up to this day, it is clear that Compound cannot compete against Maker’s $DAI stablecoin. Therefore, it is worth assessing its performance from another angle: comparing it to its most direct competitor and money market, Aave.

Aave and Compound have been competing for years for the money market throne in Ethereum mainnet. As time went by and the protocols started developing their respective V3s, Aave started showing signs of strength. Unlike Compound, Aave managed to remove incentives in their native token and even increase their market share, with more TVL and more loans underwritten, even without subsidizing borrowers with inflationary emissions.

The rise of Euler, a potentially strong competitor for the second spot in Ethereum’s lending market, was unfortunately halted by a hack incident. However, the incident does not diminish the potential impact Euler could have had in challenging Compound and Aave. After recovering the capital lost in the hack, a rebirth and rebrand of the protocol, combined with the launch of Eulerswap, might introduce a new competitive vector that reduces Compound’s market share.

While both Aave and Compound failed to gain traction on their institutional products, the announcement of Aave V3 made a lot of noise in the industry: cross-chain expansion, the ability to deposit collateral in one chain and borrow on another, a stablecoin ($GHO), e-mode, integration of RWAs… However, the same cannot be applied to Compound. With V3, Compound made a bet on simplicity. Instead of giving borrowers the choice for borrowers to take out loans in multiple assets, the new version of the protocol would restrict borrowers to take positions in $USDC. This makes it impossible to borrow other assets like $ETH or other stablecoins. As a result, leveraged looping strategies do not work.

The growth of Aave V3 has largely been driven by the appetite for leverage, more specifically through strategies where users deposit a liquid staking token like stETH to borrow $ETH, then swap $ETH back to $stETH and repeat over and over again. This attracted a lot of borrowers and provided great capital efficiency when combined with a protocol like Morpho, which can match borrowers and lenders peer-to-peer and offer a mid-market rate, effectively eliminating the spread between the borrow and supply rates.

Incentives are no longer a central component of Aave’s business model, as the protocol prioritizes a premium lending experience and places a strong emphasis on security. Aave has never experienced a hack, and shortfall events have resulted in minimal losses for Safety Module depositors. In contrast, Compound continues to emit a capped amount of $COMP daily, with predefined allocations for each market based on governance decisions. This ongoing emission approach has led to concerns about long-term sustainability.

Recently, Aave V3 has managed to surpass the TVL of Compound V2, which is still struggling with the migration to V3. Even after adopting extreme measures such as capping the borrow rate and not the supply rate, which effectively inverts the yield curve and means that the protocol gives more in liabilities than gets paid from borrowers, the liquidity is not sticky enough and the reserve gets slowly drained. If the inversion remains in place for a long enough period of time, the protocol would effectively be operating as an insolvent bank with more liabilities than assets. However, it is worth noting that the reasoning behind this decision was determined by Gauntlet as part of a risk assessment that intends to spike the earnings rate to get new capital in and that will hopefully remain in V3 afterwards.

Given the significant differences between Compound V2 and V3, borrowers may be reluctant to migrate to the newer version, favoring the flexibility provided by Compound V2. Presently, Compound retains sufficient reserves to cover more than three months if the yield inversion persists.

A Vicious Rally

The month of July witnessed a notable rally among DeFi 1.0 coins, including Aave, Maker, Compound, and Synthetix, among others. Compound’s recent gains, however, were influenced by a news story loosely connected to its platform, adding intrigue to the situation. What stands out is the fact that someone took action in $COMP before the news became widely known.

The news in question was an announcement by Compound’s founder and former CEO, Robert Leshner, regarding the launch of a new company called Superstate, which aims to tokenize US government bond ownership on Ethereum. Leshner made this announcement on Twitter at 16:43 UTC on 6/28/23.

Today, I'm excited to announce the founding of a new company, @superstatefundsSuperstate's mission is to create regulated financial products that bridge traditional markets & blockchain ecosystems.— Robert Leshner (@rleshner) June 28, 2023

Today, I'm excited to announce the founding of a new company, @superstatefunds

Superstate's mission is to create regulated financial products that bridge traditional markets & blockchain ecosystems.

— Robert Leshner (@rleshner) June 28, 2023

Leshner later mentioned that several other members of the Compound team joined him in establishing the new venture and that they filed with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).

Speculation emerged regarding a potential new source of revenue and value accrual for $COMP, despite team members leaving to pursue other ventures not being the most bullish news one might expect. The SEC filing for Superstate’s N-1A, received on the 26th (11 days after its Form D filing), references Leshner and Jim Hiltner, Compound’s former head of sales, twice. Notably, Compound itself is not mentioned in the filing, while Ethereum is referenced 15 times.

Prior to the tweet being published, prices began to rise, and on the next day, at 9:03 UTC, $COMP’s price continued to soar past the $50 mark.

These movements did not go unnoticed by the markets. Prices rose from $30.26 the day before the filing, to $63.61 on July 4. After a consistent decline for much of the year, the price has returned to its September 2022 level, after having peaked close to $809 in April 2021.

Additionally, trading volume for $COMP has surpassed previous months, seemingly driven by a factor that has no direct connection to the Compound Protocol. However, there are signs that the rally was overblown and bids have not managed to keep up.

Furthermore, when we look at the time period from June 28 (the day when Robert’s tweet came out) to July 8, 2023, we can see how $MKR has retained its strength, while $COMP has slightly retraced.

1-Trillion Asset Class – BTC, ETH & Stablecoins

Maker is a bet that decentralized stablecoins can become the next 1-trillion-dollar asset class after $BTC and $ETH. $DAI has dominated not only as the oldest and most battle-tested, but also as the most adopted stablecoin since the beginning of DeFi. This is justified by a robust mechanism design that supports its use as a store of value through the DSR as well as the use for credit by borrowing through Maker Vaults.

Over the past 2 years, the skepticism around stablecoins has increased significantly, more specifically since the collapse of $LUNA. This event reinforced the value proposition of $DAI. Many started to question whether it is actually possible to build a decentralized stablecoin that is not backed by at least 100% of its value. As an example, $FRAX reached an inflection point where it chose to abandon its original fractional reserve design and it would be 100% by $USDC. Beyond this simple anecdote lies the fact that Maker was heavily criticized when it pivoted from SAI to DAI – from Single-Asset collateral in the form of $ETH to MCD (Multi-Collateral DAI). Critics argued that by supporting $USDC as collateral, the protocol would lose its censorship-resistance and permissionless nature.

Maker – the Central Bank of DeFi

Over the past months, more and more protocols are attempting to become the “central bank of DeFi” through a pursuit of the “DeFi trinity”, which consists of protocols that have their own Dex, money market, and stablecoin. Examples of this are Curve, Aave, or Frax:

  • Curve started out as a Dex and recently launched $crvUSD under a CDP model where the stablecoin can be borrowed against crypto collateral.
  • Aave very recently deployed their $GHO stablecoin, after consolidating its place as the biggest money market.
  • Frax started out building $FRAX as a fractional reserve stablecoin and ended up developing its own dex, Fraxswap, and money market, Fraxlend to strengthen the peg through AMOs (Algorithmic Market Operations).

However, even though Maker has no plans of deploying its own Dex, it can be argued that it will still retain its place as the “central bank of DeFi”. After all, it is the only capable protocol for setting the “risk-free” rate of DeFi.

Effective June 19th, 2023, Maker hiked interest rates to 3.49%. By increasing the DSR from 1% to 3.49%, Maker effectively set a new baseline yield for stablecoins. This was later on decreased to 3.19%. However, last month this resulted in inflows of ~$170M, representing a 170% increase. Still, there is a lot of $DAI sitting on money markets (probably as collateral) earning significantly less.

So far, the hike in DSR hasn’t been sufficient to reverse the trend for the $DAI supply, though it’s managed to stop the bleeding. For context, $DAI supply is the driving force behind Maker revenues. If the $DAI supply starts to trend upwards, expect Maker revenues to follow suit.

This yield of the DSR is paid out of the surplus buffer. The protocol generates yield on its assets, and uses this revenue to compensate users who deposit their $DAI liquidity in the DSR, indirectly making it more attractive to hold $DAI (which also increases the market cap of $DAI and Maker’s revenue).

The DSR is used by Maker as a monetary policy tool that allows the protocol to shift interest rates with the goal to reach a balance between the demand and supply of $DAI. It allows $DAI holders to deposit their tokens and earn a consistent interest rate. Effectively, this yield incentivizes more users to lock their $DAI in order to take advantage of the better rate.

One of the most overlooked things about the recent rate hike is the fact DSR deposits are tokenized in the form of sDAI (Savings DAI), an ERC-4626 token (an extension of the ERC-20 standard for yield-bearing assets) which can also be used across DeFi, such as using it as collateral to borrow on money markets. This is a significant improvement in terms of capital efficiency, which is the major deficiency of over-collateralized stablecoins.

As an example, sDAI looping is effectively depositing $DAI earning at the DSR (3.19%), borrowing other stables at a lower rate, buying more $DAI, and so on and so forth. This process increases the $DAI supply, thereby increasing the amount of revenue that the protocol can achieve.

As of right now, with rather high rates on money markets, like $USDC’s borrow rate over 3%, might preclude looping. However, this is a trend that is worth keeping an eye on moving forward, since this drives more revenue generation.

The demand for sDAI is equivalent to the demand for $DAI, and an incremental demand for $DAI is likely to be facilitated through the PSM – i.e. depositing $USDC to receive $DAI. This $USDC in turn would find its way through Maker’s RWA strategy – to buy T-Bills, which would in turn mint more $DAI. This kicks off an effective flywheel that increases not only the protocol revenue but also $DAI’s supply.

Compound – Losing the Battle vs. Spark Protocol?

The DSR increase has effects that go beyond the MakerDAO ecosystem. $DAI is a fundamental component of DeFi. Therefore, this increase has ripple effects and consequences on the overall interest rates.

As explained above, the point of adjusting the DSR is to reach a delicate equilibrium between the demand and supply of $DAI. In this case, the aim is to incentivize users to lock up their $DAI in the DSR – which is considered the safest DeFi stablecoin yield. Other money markets, like Compound and Aave, will have to adapt, and borrow rates will rise accordingly.

Unlike in past DSR adjustments, Maker now can rely on the operations of its first subDAO, Spark Protocol. Spark Protocol is a fork of Aave v3 with the difference that interest rates for $DAI are not based on utilization rates. Instead, users can borrow at a fixed rate set to the DSR. This can propel the development of more sustainable and predictable fixed-yield products that can wet the appetite of fixed-income investors, which are currently underserved given the desire for leverage and inherent price volatility.

Even though Spark’s TVL is still below $30M, it keeps trending to the upside and there are ongoing integrations with Element and Sense Protocol to offer market-driven fixed borrow rates at scale. By using Element’s hyperdrive it becomes possible for borrowers to take 3/6/122 month loans without needing to attach an arbitrary maturity date.

As more fixed income products get developed on top of Spark Protocol, slowly but surely Maker is paving the way for bootstrapping the yield curve of DeFi. This has multiple benefits as it will make the cost of money more stable and predictable, which is a key driver for any economy (and DeFi is no different).

Not only that but there is an ongoing multi-chain expansion as well.

Maker and RWAs – Bridging the Gap Between Traditional and Digitized Capital Markets

The primary limiting factor to DeFi is that crypto-native assets are the only interoperable assets. This reason explains the recent rise of the RWA assets narrative. Up until now, there was nothing that TradFi could do to compete against DeFi yields. However, that started to change with the beginning of the bear market, with Treasury Bonds offering higher yield rates than DeFi protocols in terms of real yield (USD-denominated yield resulting from economic activity – excluding token emissions and incentives).

The opportunity cost of transferring money on-chain is at its greatest level in the history of crypto as a result of rising rates, declining DeFi demand, and a negative global macroeconomic environment. Real World Assets (RWAs) offer a unique opportunity not only for independent investors but also for DAO treasuries to access diverse off-chain debt markets, while also allowing TradFi institutions to tokenize and issue debt/assets, agnostic of market geography.

With DeFi expanding beyond the reach of crypto-native assets, conventional capital markets are becoming increasingly more interested in blockchain technology. In that regard, the go-to place is no other than MakerDAO.

By examining the success of securitization in the 1990s as a benchmark for capital formation, being long $MKR is effectively a bet that tokenization of RWAs can bridge the gap between traditional and digitized capital markets.

The evolution of securitization in the 1990s revolutionized capital formation by providing increased liquidity and more affordable financing options for consumers, companies, and homebuyers. However, despite its success, traditional financial markets have not fully embraced the opportunities offered by the Internet. At the same time, decentralized finance still lives in its own vacuum and struggles to find adoption in the off-chain world. Nowadays, liquidity conditions are far from being optimal in crypto.

The involvement of multiple intermediaries (investment banks, trustees, rating services, services, and other intermediaries) has resulted in higher borrowing costs and limited accessibility to international financing markets. This is one of the most obvious examples where blockchain technologies present a transformative opportunity. With the integration of RWAs, Maker DAO has the potential to unlock new collateral types, expand its ecosystem, and further increase liquidity.

  • Enhanced Liquidity: Blockchain’s fractional ownership and ease of transferability enable increased liquidity for a broader range of assets, including real estate, commodities, and intellectual property.
  • Reduced Intermediaries: Smart contracts and decentralized platforms can streamline processes, eliminate middlemen, and reduce associated costs.
  • Global Market Access: By leveraging blockchain’s decentralized nature, businesses in emerging economies can gain access to international financing markets, fostering economic growth and development.

As of May, MakerDAO’s total Real-World Asset (RWA) portfolio reached a value of 2.34 billion DAI. The allocation is shown in the image below:

We can see that RWAs made up 79.7% of all Stability Fees generated by the Maker Protocol, up from 72.6% in April. Year to date, this portfolio generated 78.5% of the total Stability Fees.

The RWA Stability Fees for MakerDAO have accumulated to 17,275,121 $DAI year-to-date (YTD), totaling 19,453,425 $DAI since inception. This increase can be attributed to the deployment of additional $DAI from the Monetalis Clydesdale vault, whose debt increased from 500M $DAI to 1.14B $DAI.

  • 53% of the vault assets are in a 0-6 month Treasury ladder.
  • 33% are 0-1yr treasury ETFs (IB01)
  • 14% are 1-3yr treasury ETFs (IBTA)

The Monetary Premium of $DAI

$DAI is by far the most adopted crypto-backed stablecoin. Despite a slight decline since April 2023, its most direct competitors, namely $FRAX and $LUSD have not experienced an uptrend in terms of market cap during that same period.

There is one fundamental difference between the backing of each of these stablecoins. Unlike $LUSD, which is only backed by $ETH and $FRAX, which is on its way to reaching a 100% collateral ratio in $USDC, $DAI is backed by more than one collateral asset, including both on-chain and off-chain collateral.

The history of $DAI and the transition for Single-Collateral $DAI to a multicollateral $DAI represents what the cost of decentralization looks like. There is a price to pay in order to find balance in the stablecoin trilemma, and having multiple collateral assets helps in that sense.

Liquity’s “premium of resiliency” resembles what $DAI looked like in its early days when $ETH was the only supported collateral asset. However, that carries on problems when it comes to keeping the price close to the target peg of 1 USD. On the other hand, the reliance on $USDC might come at the expense of censorship-resistance, and even depegging events, as was evidenced during the $USDC depeg after the collapse of SVB.

This price stability contributes to a monetary premium by which the stablecoin can be used as a medium of exchange, as debt, and as a store of value. In the case of Maker, these functions are clearly differentiated: $DAI has integrations in major money markets like Aave and Compound, deep liquidity in primary Dexes like Uniswap and Curve, can be borrowed against supported collateral assets in Maker Vaults, and be used as savings by depositing in the DSR (Dai Savings Rate) to earn a guaranteed yield distributed from Maker’s profits.

Maker – Bullish Outlook

Maker’s revenue in Q2 has put its native token in the spotlight. Slowly but surely, the annual estimates show that the protocol could triple its numbers if expenses and parameters remain stable.

By reducing its $USDC exposure from over 50% to 9% and replacing it with yield-generating RWAs (mostly T-Bills), Maker has successfully quadrupled its earnings. Right now, Maker is trading at 9.2x earnings

This recent increase in terms of revenue can be attributed to the recent increase in stability fees (fees charged to $DAI borrowers) combined with a more efficient allocation of treasury assets (MIP65).

Even though the revenue has been improving since April, it has not been until June that the market has caught up to this awakening. From reaching a low of 0.281 $ETH, $MKR has almost doubled in price relative to $ETH.

Despite the positive price action and outperformance relative to other alts, this growth is still lower than the 3x achieved in profits.

This has caused the P/E multiples to compress over the past months.

One key metric to keep an eye on is $DAI’s market cap. Given the current parameters, every unit of $DAI in circulation is incrementally more profitable after the hike in stability fees and reallocation of the balance sheet. Despite the emergence of more and more decentralized stablecoins ($LUSD, $FRAX, LST-backed stablecoins…), $DAI is still the most dominant player with over $4B in market cap. This is more than 4 times the market cap of the second largest stablecoin backed by crypto, $FRAX.

Additionally, the last two US-based VCs, a16z and Paradigm have already capitulated. Paradigm unloaded 4 months ago, while a16z is in the process of liquidating its $MKR holdings right now. Interestingly enough, both are using the same desk to execute. Polychain and Dragonfly offloaded all their $MKR years ago as well.

In the meantime, after one month and a half, Rune, the largest holder and founder of MakerDAO, continues to buy even more $MKR. This shows he is one of the few DeFi founders who has ever purchased more of their own token. As a de facto decision-maker, at least his decisions align with holders, and he’s clearly committed.

What Could Cause a Reprice?

Robert Leshner, the founder of Compound Labs, has recently announced that he will be founding a new company, Superstate Funds. The goal behind this startup is to give DeFi investors an easy way to get access to real-world yield. This reinforces the thesis that Compound is lagging in that realm and is far behind Maker and Aave, which have already started to integrate RWAs as a key component of their business models. If Superstate’s new product Short-Term Government Bond Fund was approved, it would offer blockchain native funds a way to access the returns on government debt without changing their approach to portfolio management.

Beyond this goal, Superstate’s mission is to create regulated financial products that bridge traditional markets & blockchain ecosystems. With that in mind, Robert Leshner and his team filled a preliminary prospectus with the SEC for the Superstate Short-Term Government Bond Fund. After a $4M seed raise and backed by investors that are heavily involved with Crypto, like Parafi, 1kx, Cumberland, or Coinfund among others, it was rumored that value might flow to the $COMP token. While that’s a reasonable expectation, Compound Labs is a completely different entity, now under the direction of a new CEO. The Compound DAO, which governs the Compound protocol itself through the $COMP token, is even more separated from Superstate. For that reason, we expect that, in the short to medium term, there will be no significant catalysts that will cause $COMP to significantly appreciate as a result of this. What’s more, this suggests that the $COMP rally might have been overblown by some news that might take months or years to materialize into something significant.

As we evidenced above, the actions of individuals with early knowledge played a significant role in generating interest in the coin and encouraging traders, who constantly seek volatility, to take larger positions. However, the question remains: if Superstate’s fund receives SEC approval (which is uncertain), will it have any impact on Compound? The initial filing did not reference Compound, and that may give us a clue as to whether this rally was justified.

Finally, it is worth noting that $MKR plays a key role in ensuring the solvency of the system, and this might come at the expense of the token’s price. The famous “Black Thursday” event is an example of this, where untimely liquidations led to the accumulation of bad debt in the protocol. In this scenario, the solution used by Maker is to mint and auction $MKR, diluting the supply with the objective of covering the losses.

However, one cannot understate the fact that protocol revenue is used to buy and burn $MKR. Not only that, but there is also a proposal suggesting that has now been passed and by which, instead of buying and burning $MKR, $MKR could be bought with the $DAI generated from protocol fees in order to be paired with excess $DAI from the Surplus Buffer (activated when the funds exceed $50M – currently at $70M) and allocate that liquidity to the Uniswap v2 $MKR/$DAI pool as protocol owned liquidity. While this $MKR could otherwise be burned, this might improve liquidity conditions on-chain, reducing volatility and making it safer to protect the protocol during Black-Swan events such as Black Thursday.

If implemented, this would stop all $MKR burning, cut in half the system’s buying pressure on $MKR, and start storing buybacks in the Treasury. These buybacks might at a later point be spent meaning the $MKR is only temporarily out of circulation.

However, this decision comes out of multiple discussions within the Maker community, with an overall consensus that there’s really no difference between the protocol holding MKR vs. burning it. The protocol is equally able to mint and sell MKR as it is to sell MKR it holds.

The Smart Burn Engine

With the Smart Burn Engine being activated, $MKR’s buyback program will be restarted, and these newly bought back $MKR tokens will be paired with $DAI into a Uniswap V2 LP pool.

In the past, Maker switched off this mechanism on February 1, 2022, when the protocol was annualizing $20M in profit. Today, the profit is more than 4x that amount, ~$86M (and there are no reasons why the RWA yield won’t increase this amount past the $100M mark), with half of it being allocated to the Smart Burn Engine.

As more $MKR is purchased, the liquidity conditions improve as well. This might not imply a direct value accrual in terms of price but suggests a significant improvement in terms of tokenomics that might cause a repricing. A gradual appreciation in the $MKR price, together with a price stability mechanism, can induce re-rating as a result of an increasing amount in buy flows.

At this pace, Maker would be buying back around $7.5M $MKR per month.

Key Takeaways

  • While MakerDAO and Compound Finance are each distinct in their own right, they are similar in that they provide borrowing or lending options to both passive and more aggressive players.
  • Compound risks falling behind its competition in the money market and borrowing/ lending space, as it prioritizes endeavors that involve institutions.
  • Aave recently launched their $GHO stablecoin and has found success in expanding to other chains and with their e-Mode.
  • Compound is already overvalued, off the back of a massive rally in July that affected other Bluechip DeFi tokens.
  • MakerDAO is bridging the gap between DeFi and RWAs, with the DAO’s significant exposure RWAs including treasury bonds.
  • Spark, the first subDAO of MakerDAO, is an Aave v3 fork that could also have some competitive advantages compared to Compound.
  • MakerDAO is making moves that suggest it could maintain its lead as issuer of the primary crypto-backed stablecoin, and the biggest influence over stablecoin rates in DeFi.

Conclusion

Just as banks become more profitable in a rising rate environment, Maker is establishing itself as the central bank of crypto and capitalizing on the unique opportunity of bridging the worlds of TradFi and DeFi.

All things considered, Maker is paying out more interest to depositors while simultaneously earning more interest as income from lending. As that net income continues to increase, so does the profitability of the protocol.

Unlike $COMP’s price action, the outperformance of $MKR can be attributed to multiple factors:

  • Increased revenue from fees, averaging $315,000 daily and increasing significantly since the start of the year
  • The rapid growth of Spark, the first subDAO and lending platform that uses a credit line from Maker, the Dai Direct Deposit Module (D3M)
  • As time goes by and the progressive Endgame roadmap development unfolds, $MKR’s price action might be pricing in Maker’s new tokenomics and ecosystem development.

Disclosures

Revelo Intel has never had a commercial relationship with Maker DAO or Compound and this report was not paid for or commissioned in any way.

Members of the Revelo Intel team, including those directly involved in the analysis above, may have positions in the tokens discussed.

This content is provided for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice. You should do your own research and only invest what you can afford to lose. Revelo Intel is a research platform and not an investment or financial advisor.

Alea Research · 22 Jul 2023 · 26 min · 17 sections

Back to top