From Exchange to Crypto Super App
Coinbase, often viewed as a crypto exchange, is often analyzed through the lens of Wall Street analysts via earnings and multiple estimates that, even though might be accurate, fail to capture the second and third order effects that certain initiatives can have on its valuation.

Source: TradingView as per of 2024/04/24 – Coinbase Global, Inc daily prices since April 2021
Our thesis poses that most quantifiable metrics fail to fully capture the evolving business dynamics of Coinbase. We posit that Coinbase is transitioning towards a “crypto super app,” strategically positioning itself beyond its exchange roots.
We argue that $COIN is a way to express a bullish outlook on the total market cap of crypto. Coinbase dominance is still far from ATH when the past bull market crypto peaked at $3T in 2021. Since then Coinbase has largely diversified its revenue streams, expanded its user base and operations globally through Base and an international derivatives platform, and served a key role as the custodian for multiple spot ETFs.
Source: SeekingAlpha, CoinMarketCap.com

$COIN earnings will be released on May 2nd, and we believe that whether they are positive or negative, this might present good opportunities to enter a position at lower prices. Our view is that there is no need to FOMO and buy ahead of the results, as we see plenty of opportunities to accumulate later down the road.

Source: YCharts – Coinbase Key Stats
Key Takeaways
- Coinbase is transitioning from a primary focus on being a crypto exchange to becoming a “crypto super app”.
- With $COIN earnings to be released soon, the anticipation is that fluctuations—whether positive or negative—may provide strategic buying opportunities down the road.
- Over the past two years, Coinbase has successfully diversified its revenue from predominantly retail trading fees to a mix that includes substantial contributions from areas like Coinbase Cloud, cbETH liquid staking, and ETF custody services.
- Coinbase is vertically integrating various services into a unified platform, which is likely to increase the lifetime value of its users by enhancing user engagement and increasing transaction frequency.
- As institutional interest in the crypto market grows, Coinbase’s strategic positioning allows it to serve as a bridge between TradFi and DeFi.
- Regulatory uncertainties and the high volatility of crypto could impact Coinbase’s business operations and stock performance.
- Despite the positives, there are concerns about Coinbase’s current valuation, suggesting it might be elevated given its earnings multiples compared to other more traditional financial institutions.
Background
Founded in 2012 by Brian Armstrong and Fred Ehrsam when $BTC was trading below $10, Coinbase was established with the mission to make crypto accessible and easy to use for the general public. Originating as a simple platform for users to buy and sell Bitcoin, the company aimed to eliminate the technical barriers associated with blockchains, advocating for broader financial inclusion and innovation.
The second asset listing didn’t hit the exchange until the launch of $ETH in 2015. Twelve years later, Coinbase has evolved significantly, rapidly expanding beyond $BTC and adding support for a variety of networks. Achieving a major milestone, the company went public in April 2021 via a direct listing.
With the demise of FTX and Binance exiting the US, Coinbase remains the only crypto exchange in the US public markets, making it a safe bet for investors looking to get exposure to the fast growth of crypto as an asset class. The approval of $BTC spot ETFs have helped to legitimize the industry, and large asset managers like Blackrock and Fidelity have trusted Coinbase as their custodian.
As a publicly traded company with oversight from regulators, $COIN can be used as a proxy to avoid the inherent volatility of $BTC. Coinbase also allows us to get exposure to a diversified business model with cash flow from a variety of sources (Coinbase Cloud, cbETH liquid staking, ETF custody services, Smart Wallets, Base sequencer fees, etc.). Furthermore, Wall Street analysts are already familiar with pricing businesses based on metrics such as cash flows or revenue multiples. These quantitative metrics are appealing to a certain type of investors who can’t fully understand the intrinsic value of a digital commodity like $BTC.
Overview
Investors often question the advantage of investing in Coinbase over directly purchasing majors like $BTC or $ETH. However, there are distinct, often overlooked benefits associated with investing in equities like $COIN. Unlike direct asset purchases, Coinbase offers a broader exposure through a diversified business model that captures value across the entire crypto stack—from ETFs to crypto-native applications on Base.

Source: YCharts – Coinbase is up 216% in the last 6 months
Coinbase provides a unique blend of retail and institutional offerings, spanning from Coinbase Cloud, liquid staking (cbETH), custody services for ETFs, offshore derivatives, and on-chain activity on Base. The first order effects are derived from its direct exposure to the industry, but Coinbase also captures indirect benefits from positive industry developments, increasing overall engagement and usage of the platform. This diversity of revenue streams with a combination of retail and institutional offerings gives us more flexibility and optionality when adjusting a portfolio.
For instance, consider how improvements in developer experience like the launch of Coinbase Smart Wallets can increase the on-chain activity on Base, further onboarding new users and increasing the participation and volume of Coinbase as the go-to centralized exchange.
Even though Coinbase is not the only CEX that is incubating its own on-chain ecosystem of applications (i.e. Binance with BSC, OKX with OKTC. etc.), it definitely stands out for occupying a sweet spot at the efficient frontier between legitimacy, reputation, and popularity.
The last cycle was led by retail with the expectation that institutions were coming. This cycle we are starting to see signs of institutional capital entering the space, as reflected by ETFs and Bitcoin-led dominance. However, retail has not arrived yet. At some point both market participants will coexist, with Coinbase as the connecting tissue between degens on Base and ETF issuers on its exchange.

Source: The Block – Coinbase’s Overall Trading Volume and the Proportion Attributable to the Retail Segment.
We are starting to see the first signs of vertical integration, allowing users to access a wide range of services through a single, unified application. As the adoption of crypto grows, the diversity and depth of Coinbase’s offerings are expected to significantly increase the lifetime value of its users. Each new feature and service not only attracts new users but also increases the engagement of existing ones, promoting a higher frequency of transactions and a broader use of the platform’s features.

Source: Coinbase products
Sector Outlook
With the recent collapse of FTX and Binance’s exit from the U.S. market, Coinbase has not only grown its market share in America. Given the ongoing regulatory obstacles, Coinbase has strategically launched an international derivatives exchange, tapping into a crucial market segment where it had previously been inactive. Even though this is currently a low take rate endeavor (~3 bps), its growth continues to churn higher volumes at approximately $1.1B/day.

Source: CoinGecko, Coinbase International Exchange – Last 30d volume is $34.52B, with the ATH being reached on Mar 20, 2024 at $6.14B
The entry of institutional investors into the crypto market is becoming increasingly evident. There is a growing sophistication among investors, accompanied by a need for deeper analytical understanding of this space. The launch of spot $BTC ETFs has served as the gateway for traditional investors to engage with Bitcoin. As these investors grow more comfortable with Bitcoin, their curiosity is likely to extend to other aspects of the crypto world such as Ethereum, Solana, smart contracts, NFTs, etc.
For Coinbase, this progression is particularly beneficial. As new users deepen their engagement with the crypto ecosystem, they are more likely to utilize Coinbase’s diverse services for trading, staking, and participating in on-chain activities, driving increased traffic and transactions through the platform. This not only enhances Coinbase’s user base but also bolsters its position as a central hub in the cryptocurrency market.
Strategic Investments and their Impact on Valuations
Coinbase’s financials, primarily driven by exchange volumes, have historically posed challenges for equity analysts, often leading to missed earnings projections. The difficulty lies in accurately estimating the mix of retail and institutional clients and the variable fee structures across different services. Additionally, the adoption of new financial accounting rules by FASB, allowing companies to mark up crypto holdings on balance sheets as prices rise, is likely to significantly affect net income and EPS projections for Coinbase. Yet, many analysts might still be underestimating this impact.

Source: SeekingAlpha – Last 4 estimates have been beaten by actual EPS.
Coinbase Ventures, as a leading venture capitalist in the sector since the early days of crypto, holds strategic positions marked at historical cost. The revaluation of these assets could reveal substantial gains, further enhancing its financial standing. For example, ventures initially marked at hundreds of millions could potentially be worth billions today, reflecting a significant increase. Currently these assets are reflected in the balance sheet at the initial raise valuation instead of actual market valuation. Additionally, some projects don’t have a liquid token yet.

Source: YCharts – Coinbase Financials
The Myopic View on the Impact of Spot ETFs
While some critics argue that spot Bitcoin ETFs might cannibalize Coinbase’s trading volumes (i.e. why would anyone buy $BTC on Coinbase when they can get exposure through Fidelity or Schwab), this perspective overlooks the broader implications. We assert that ETFs are likely a net positive for Coinbase due to increased custodial revenue and trading volumes stemming from ETF issuance and redemption processes. Furthermore, ETFs are expected to contribute to an overall increase in the crypto market cap, indirectly benefiting Coinbase.
On the exchange listing side of things we are starting to see an acceleration on the listing of new assets, as well as ongoing initiatives aimed at onboarding millions of users on-chain. For Coinbase, this progression is particularly beneficial. As new users deepen their engagement with the industry, they are more likely to utilize Coinbase’s diverse services for trading, staking, and participating in on-chain activities, driving increased traffic and transactions through the platform.
We argue that the spot ETFs are a net positive for Coinbase because of the custodial fees, revenue from issuance and redemptions, and the ongoing Surveillance Sharing Agreement (SSA). Besides, we also believe that the second order effects will continue to increase the total market cap of crypto, progressively achieving an optimal ratio of ETF trading volume to spot secondary market activity, and Coinbase will be the recipient of those trading volumes.
Thesis
The appeal for building a position on $COIN is anchored in its robust business performance, strategic market positioning, and its role as a barometer for the broader crypto market. Factors such as higher crypto prices, increased staking yields, and rising assets under management all contribute to heightened trading volumes and custodial fees, boosting Coinbase’s revenue.

Source: TradingView as of 2024/04/24 – $COIN vs $TOTAL daily prices comparison
Investing in Coinbase is effectively a bet on the overall growth of the cryptocurrency market. Events that elevate the market cap of crypto, such as the potential issuance of a Bitcoin spot ETF by major players like BlackRock and Fidelity in partnership with Coinbase, will likely have a multiplicative effect on the company’s earnings. This is analogous to how asset managers like BlackRock benefit from rising AUM in their ETFs.
Furthermore, the introduction of spot ETFs is expected to attract a broader array of investors, enhancing overall market attention. This increased engagement benefits Coinbase directly by expanding its customer base, not just among those comfortable with traditional investment vehicles like ETFs, but also those who venture deeper into altcoins and decentralized exchanges on-chain.
Global Expansion and Derivatives Market
Coinbase’s international expansion and its competencies across both centralized and decentralized platforms position it well to capture a meaningful share of the global crypto transactions. For many, this will answer the question about why to invest in $COIN instead of buying crypto.

Source: TradingView as of 2024/04/24 – $TOTAL vs $COIN performance (indexed to 100) since 2023
This strategic move allows Coinbase to hedge against regulatory risks in the US, diversify its geographic revenue sources, and tap into the significant revenue potential of the global derivatives market. The absence of a user interface (UI) on this platform emphasizes its focus on institutional clients, who prioritize functionality and regulatory compliance over user-friendly design.
ETF Custody and Increased Trading Volume
Coinbase has become a custodian for nine spot ETF issuers, a significant endorsement that not only stamps its approval in the industry but also drives substantial custody revenues. The creation and redemption of ETF shares, coupled with secondary market trading, will likely increase trading volumes, particularly in the BTC-USD pair. This positions Coinbase to benefit from future ETF launches, including potential $ETH ETFs, enhancing its role in bridging traditional finance with crypto.
Growth of Base and Ecosystem Development
Base, Coinbase’s Layer 2 solution, is showing impressive growth with daily active users increasing significantly. Even though the current priority is to act as a developer platform, it already boasts a thriving app ecosystem and a liquid capital market with over $100M in stablecoins. The monetization through sequencer fees, coupled with the strategic launch of smart wallets, simplifies on-chain transactions, attracting more users and boosting overall trading volumes on Coinbase.

Source: Artemis.xyz
Despite Coinbase’s diverse revenue streams, Wall Street often underestimates its cyclicality and the reflexive nature of the crypto market. Analysts frequently focus excessively on the bank-like aspect of its business model, such as interest income from $USDC holdings. However, this conservative view overlooks Coinbase’s potential in transaction fees and offerings like Base and Coinbase Cloud.

Source: Token Terminal – Top 5 projects in cumulative revenue
The growth in active wallet addresses is also quite meaningful, with DAUs going from 92k in March 13th to 350k in April 23rd.

Source: Token Terminal
We can also assess that the stickiness of users has been relatively high, even when the majority of the market participants still don’t expect to see a native token or incentives in the near term.

Source: Artemis.xyz – New vs returning users show that daily active returning addresses are above 75% on average
We are seeing in real-time how Base benefits significantly from the strong brand value of its parent company. This association acts as a magnet, attracting a plethora of projects eager to be part of a platform backed by a reputable and trusted name in the industry. Base currently hosts more than 200 projects with over $1.5B in TVL.

As a neutral Layer 2 (L2) solution, many teams that don’t know what L2 to choose for deploying their applications are very likely to end up deploying in Base. This also applies to teams in other chains who want to extend their operations and go where most users are, and take advantage of the simple transfer experience from Coinbase into Base. For instance, Base is now the second chain with bridged $USDC only after Ethereum.

Source: usdc.cool
More $USDC on Base translates into a higher pro rata share of the interest income generated on $USDC assets by Circle.

Source: Token Terminal
The speculative introduction of a $BASE token will present an intriguing scenario in the upcoming months. Such a token could enable Coinbase to capture value similar to other L2 tokens like Optimism ($OP) and Arbitrum ($ARB), enhancing its revenue streams through token economics. More importantly, a $BASE token could facilitate further decentralization of the platform, potentially increasing its appeal as infrastructure critical to businesses and bolstering its claim to true decentralization. This is reflected in the increase in Base’s mindshare starting in March.

Source: kaito.ai
Base is directly monetized through sequencer fees, which are a direct source of revenue. Indirectly, it also contributes to the broader Coinbase ecosystem by increasing the overall size of the crypto market Coinbase taps into. This expansion is not just limited to enhancing trading volumes and subscriptions but also includes growing the sequencer profits and network effects that are vital for sustained revenue growth.

Source: Tokenterminal – Key on-chain stats
The business model of Base is straightforward, as it revolves around transaction fees generated from user activities minus the Layer 1 settlement and data availability (DA) costs. These operations create a profit margin of 68% that Coinbase can capitalize on annually, underscoring the platform’s potential as a lucrative component of Coinbase’s broader business strategy.

Source: Dune
This setup is reminiscent of Amazon’s AWS: Coinbase started operating a consumer product and cryptocurrency exchange that requires top-notch infrastructure and now they will dedicate internal resources to grow Base, further scaling and accelerating its growth given the permissionless nature of blockchains.
To put things into perspective, even though Base represents ~1% of Coinbase’s headcount, Base’s on-chain earnings (fee revenue – Superchain revenue share – L1 settlement and DA costs) annualized from the past 30 days of the year to ~$8M or ~8% of Coinbase’s net income in 2023. Note that these earnings exclude all off-chain personnel and other infrastructure or operational costs.
Invalidations
Despite Coinbase’s apparent success, several factors could invalidate a bullish thesis and pose significant risks to the investment in the short term. These concerns include the company’s high valuation, dependency on the volatility of the crypto market, regulatory challenges, and operational risks associated with global expansion. These are the reasons why we advocate for waiting and being patient, as we believe there will be plenty of opportunities to buy lower and still manage to ride the upcoming and strongest trend of the bull cycle.
Coinbase is currently trading at approximately 10x forward sales and 93x forward earnings, suggesting that the market may have already priced in many of the positives. Such a lofty valuation raises concerns about the sustainability of its stock price, especially if growth expectations are not met. For reference, below you can find a graph of the outsized forward P/E multiple for Coinbase vs. regular brokers/banks/exchanges that you could own as alternatives. Although there are some nuances, each of those have actual earnings built over years.

Source: YCharts
Acknowledged in their latest 10-K Annual Report, the fortunes of Coinbase are closely tied to the fluctuations of the cryptocurrency market. Historical data shows high volatility in Coinbase’s stock, which could present substantial downside risk for investors if the crypto market faces downturns. The company’s revenue is highly dependent on transaction volumes and crypto asset prices, which are themselves subject to drastic swings. Within subscription and services revenue, a meaningful concentration is from transactions in Bitcoin, Ethereum and stablecoin revenue in connection with $USDC. If revenue from these areas declines and is not replaced by new demand, operating results could be adversely affected.

Source: YCharts
Even though Coinbase has always insisted that transactions on its platform don’t qualify as securities, a US District Judge has endorsed the SEC’s stand that some crypto trades on Coinbase’s platform meet the long-standing definition of an investment contract. Despite efforts to engage transparently with regulators, there remains a lack of clarity regarding regulatory concerns, which adds to the uncertainty.
Additionally, as Coinbase expands globally, it faces increasing complexities due to the need to comply with diverse laws and regulations across different jurisdictions. This expansion raises the potential for inquiries, investigations, and enforcement actions by both U.S. and international regulators, which could impact operations and financial conditions.
Timing Entries / Exits
Given the fact that all positive tailwinds may already be priced in, the upcoming earnings might have a very subtle impact. Instead, what matters is the future outlook and expectations that are set after the fact. We can use the most recent Meta’s and Tesla’s earnings as an example. The former had great earnings but the stock fell in price due to how much they are spending. Meanwhile, Tesla’s earnings were disappointing but the price soared due to speculation around a “Robotaxi Network” and “Humanoid Robot”.
For Coinbase, despite potential volatility post-earnings on May 2nd, our strategy does not hinge on immediate post-earnings performance. We anticipate that any temporary declines in stock price post-earnings could provide attractive entry points for long-term investment. Our approach is cautious; we advise against pre-earnings speculation, favoring a more measured entry post-release.
Earnings often beat estimates because the system in which they are predicted is inherently biased towards underestimation. Analysts typically set lower expectations for company earnings, which, while reducing the risk of negative surprises for investors and protecting analyst reputations, allows companies to frequently report earnings that exceed these conservative forecasts. This consistent underestimation skews the perceived reality during earnings seasons, making true financial health harder to discern.
Further complicating the investment timing is the ongoing regulatory ambiguity surrounding crypto. While Coinbase has sought clarity from regulators like the SEC, the lack of definitive guidance remains a significant risk factor.
Conclusion
Coinbase’s trajectory towards becoming a crypto super app, combined with its strategic initiatives and strengthening market position, underpins our bullish stance. We view Coinbase not just as a bet on crypto but as a diversified platform poised for substantial growth amidst increasing market and regulatory maturity.
As an actionable insight we advocate for monitoring $COIN’s performance closely around the earnings release, ready to capitalize on potential market mispricings. Our recommendation is to prepare for a strategic buy following the earnings announcement, leveraging potential short-term market irrationality for long-term gains.
References
- Coinbase Financial SEC Filings
- Coinbase 2024 Roadmap
- Coinbase Investor Relations
- Coinbase Market Capitalization
- Coinbase Global, Inc 2023 – 10k
- Coinbase Q4 2023 Shareholder Letter
- Coinbase Annual Meeting of Stockholders 2024
- Coinbase Announces Data of Q1 2024 Financial Results
- Coinbase First Quarter 2024 Earnings Call
- Coinbase Q1 2024 Earnings Q&A
- Coinbase Overall Trading Volume and Retail Contribution
- Coinbase International Exchange (Derivatives) – CoinGecko
- Coinbase International Exchange (Derivatives) – Coinbase
- Coinbase EPS Surprise & Estimates by Quarter
- Coinbase Wallet SDK
- Coinbase Cloud – Account Abstraction Kit
- Coinbase Ventures Portfolio
- Total Crypto Market Capitalization
- Base Metrics (Artemis.xyz)
- Base Metrics (Token Terminal)
- Base DefiLlama
- Base channel on Farcaster
- Base Grants Program
- Base and Rollup Economics (Dune Analytics)
- Base Blog (Mirror)
- YCharts $COIN Valuation
- Usdc.cool
- Kaito.ai
- Coinbase Exchange (Coingecko)
- Coinbase International Exchange Derivatives (Coingecko)
- Coinbase Transaction Revenue Calculator (Delphi Digital)
- Bitcoin ETF Tracker (Blockworks Research)
Disclosures
Alea Research has never had a commercial relationship with Coinbase and this report was not paid for or commissioned in any way.
Members of the Alea Research team, including those directly involved in the analysis above, may have positions in the tokens discussed.
This content is provided for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice. You should do your own research and only invest what you can afford to lose. Alea Research is a research platform and not an investment or financial advisor.


